Cherreads

Chapter 5 - Chapter 5: The First Time I Was Afraid of Him

I didn't understand what had just happened between us.

I only knew that something had changed.

Not outside.

Not in the shadows or the quiet, watching darkness that seemed to follow me.

But here—between me and him.

Lucian.

The way he had looked at me… it lingered long after his hand left my skin. I could still feel it, like a warmth that refused to fade, like something had settled under my ribs and made a home there without asking permission.

It should have scared me.

Maybe it did.

Just not in the way it should have.

The café felt smaller now, quieter, like the walls were holding their breath around us. I stepped back, not because I wanted distance—but because I needed to think, needed to breathe without feeling like he was too close, too aware, too much.

"You keep doing that," I said softly, wrapping my arms around myself as if that could steady something inside me.

"Doing what?" His voice was calm, but there was something underneath it. Something that hadn't been there before.

"Answering without answering," I replied, meeting his gaze again. "Saying things that don't make sense… but somehow feel like they do."

His lips curved slightly—not quite a smile, but close enough to make my heart stumble in a way that felt unfair.

"That's because you're asking questions you're not ready for."

The words should have annoyed me.

Instead, they unsettled me.

"And you get to decide that?" I asked.

"Yes."

The certainty in his voice made something inside me tighten.

"Why?"

He didn't answer.

Of course he didn't.

Instead, he just looked at me again—like he was measuring something, weighing something, deciding something I wasn't a part of.

And suddenly, that calm I had been feeling around him… it cracked.

Just a little.

"Lucian," I said, my voice quieter now, more serious, "what are you not telling me?"

For a moment, everything stilled.

The air.

The silence.

Even him.

And then—

something shifted.

Not in a way I could see.

In a way I could feel.

The temperature dropped just slightly, enough to make my skin prickle. The shadows in the corners of the café stretched a little longer, a little darker, like they were responding to something unseen.

My breath caught.

"What… is that?" I whispered.

His gaze didn't move from me.

"It's still here."

My heart skipped.

"What is?"

He didn't answer.

Instead, his eyes flickered—just for a second—toward the window behind me.

And that was enough.

I turned.

Slowly.

Carefully.

Like I already knew I wouldn't like what I saw.

At first, there was nothing.

Just the reflection of the café lights against the glass.

Just the empty street beyond it.

But then—

it moved.

A shadow.

Not natural.

Not normal.

It stretched unnaturally along the ground, crawling toward the door like it was alive, like it was searching.

For me.

My chest tightened, my fingers curling into the fabric of my sleeve as fear finally—finally—settled properly into my body.

"It's back," I whispered.

"Yes."

His voice was different now.

Lower.

Colder.

Not soft anymore.

Not careful.

Something else.

Something that didn't belong to the man who had touched my face like I was fragile.

Something that belonged to something far more dangerous.

"What do we do?" I asked, my voice barely steady.

Silence.

And then—

"Nothing."

I turned back to him sharply. "Nothing?"

He stepped forward.

And for the first time since I met him—

I felt it.

Not calm.

Not safety.

Power.

Raw.

Uncontained.

Terrifying.

"You stay here," he said quietly.

"And you?"

His eyes darkened.

"I deal with it."

A chill ran through me.

Something about the way he said it—

not worried.

Not uncertain.

Just absolute—

made my heart beat faster for an entirely different reason.

"Lucian…" I started, but the words died in my throat as he moved past me.

He didn't rush.

Didn't hesitate.

Just walked toward the door like the thing outside wasn't something to fear—

but something that had made a mistake.

My mistake.

Letting him go alone.

"Wait—" I called out, stepping after him.

But the moment his hand touched the door—

everything changed.

The lights flickered violently.

The air grew heavier.

And the shadow outside—

stopped moving.

Like it knew.

Like it understood.

My breath caught as I watched, unable to look away.

Lucian paused for just a second, his back to me, his hand still resting on the door.

And then—

very slowly—

he turned his head.

Not fully.

Just enough.

Enough for me to see his eyes.

And for the first time—

they weren't just dark.

They were glowing.

A deep, unnatural red.

Not human.

Not even close.

My heart dropped into my stomach.

"Lucian…?" I whispered, my voice trembling in a way I couldn't control.

He looked at me.

Really looked at me.

And for a moment—

just a moment—

there was something in his expression that almost felt like regret.

Like he hadn't wanted me to see this.

Not yet.

But it was too late.

Because I had.

I had seen it.

The truth.

Or at least a piece of it.

And suddenly—

everything made sense.

The way he knew.

The way he wasn't afraid.

The way the shadows avoided him.

The way he looked at me—

like I was something he had already decided belonged to him.

"You should go inside," he said quietly.

Like nothing had changed.

Like I hadn't just seen something impossible.

My breath came out uneven.

"What… are you?"

The question slipped out before I could stop it.

Before I could think.

Before I could prepare myself for the answer.

And this time—

he didn't look away.

Didn't avoid it.

Didn't deflect.

He just stood there.

Watching me.

With those inhuman eyes.

And something in his expression shifted again—

not softer.

Not warmer.

Darker.

More real.

More honest than anything he had shown me before.

"Not something you should be standing this close to," he said.

A shiver ran through me.

Not just fear.

Something else.

Something deeper.

Because even now—

even after seeing that—

I hadn't stepped back.

Hadn't run.

Hadn't told him to leave.

And I didn't know why.

Maybe I should have.

Maybe I still could.

But I didn't move.

I couldn't.

Because as terrifying as he suddenly felt—

as wrong as everything about this was—

there was still something pulling me toward him.

Something that made my heart beat faster instead of slower.

Something that whispered—

stay.

And I hated it.

I hated that I wasn't running.

I hated that I was still standing there, looking at him like I wanted him to stay.

Even now.

Even like this.

Because the truth was—

I wasn't just afraid of what he was.

I was afraid of what I was becoming around him.

And I had a feeling…

this was only the beginning. 

More Chapters