Cherreads

Chapter 9 - THE TRUTH HE WILL NOT TELL

Emma's POV

I walk out of the diner and I don't know where I'm going.

My mind is spinning. Liam followed me. He broke his promise. He came to Willowbrook because of me not because of some desire for a quiet life. He's been manipulating the situation this whole time.

I should be furious. I should be terrified.

But I'm not.

I walk through the snow toward the forest that borders the village. My jacket is too thin and my hands are shaking but I don't care. I need to think. I need to figure out what I'm feeling.

The truth is I've known he was lying since the moment I saw him on the street that first time. My gut screamed it. But I let him stay anyway because something about him felt safe. Something about him felt like coming home even though I've never met him before in my life that I can remember.

I find a bench at the edge of the forest and I sit down. Snow falls around me. The world is quiet except for the sound of my own breathing.

Why am I not angry about the lie.

Because it's not really a lie, a voice inside me says. It's the truth he's trying to tell you without scaring you.

And that's the problem isn't it. Something about Liam Hayes scares me. Something about the way he looks at me like I'm the most important thing in the world terrifies me.

But it also makes me feel safe.

I think about the truck. How he fixed it without asking for anything in return. I think about the snow he shoveled. The flour he carried. The coffee he bought me. Every small gesture was him showing me who he is when he's not whatever he was before.

I think about his face when he admitted the truth. He looked scared. Like telling me would destroy him if I walked away.

And I did walk away.

My phone buzzes. A text from Grace.

Where are you. Worried.

I text back that I'm fine and I'm thinking. Grace responds with a thumbs up. She knows me well enough to let me have space when I need it.

I sit on that bench for an hour thinking about Liam.

I think about how he looks at me. Not like I'm a conquest. Not like I'm something to own. Like I'm someone worth understanding.

I think about the way my heart races when he's near. I think about how I notice when he's in the bakery even though I try not to. I think about how I engineered situations to talk to him even though I told myself I wouldn't.

My body remembers him.

Even though my mind can't place him, every cell in my body knows Liam Hayes. And it's been trying to tell me that he's important. That he matters.

The realization hits me like a wave.

I've been falling for him this whole time.

Since the moment I saw him across the street at the bakery, something in me recognized him. Not as a memory but as a feeling. A pull. Something primal and impossible to deny.

And he's known it. He's been patient with me. He's been giving me space while also making sure I knew he was here. He's been showing me who he is piece by piece.

That's not manipulation.

That's love.

The thought terrifies me more than anything else has.

What if my memories come back and I realize I was wrong about him. What if I remember a life with him that I didn't want. What if loving him now ruins everything I've built here.

But what if I don't let him try.

What if I walk away and spend the rest of my life wondering what could have been.

I stand up and I brush the snow off my pants. I know what I need to do.

I walk back to the diner but Liam is gone. I go to the general store and ask where he lives. The owner tells me about the cabin at the edge of town by the mill.

It takes me twenty minutes to find it.

The cabin is small and dark and it looks like nobody has made it a home yet. When I knock, Liam opens the door and his entire body goes rigid.

"Emma," he says. Like my name is a question.

"Can we talk," I ask.

He steps aside and lets me in.

The cabin is sparse. A bed. A table. A few belongings. It looks like the home of someone who's just passing through. Someone who hasn't committed to staying.

"I'm angry," I say without preamble. "I'm angry that you lied to me. I'm angry that you followed me. I'm angry that you've been orchestrating these moments even if they feel like coincidence."

Liam watches me carefully. He doesn't interrupt.

"But I'm also angry at myself," I continue. "Because I knew. Some part of me knew you were lying and I didn't care. Because I liked having you around. I liked talking to you. I liked the way you make me feel."

"Emma," Liam starts.

"Let me finish," I say. "I don't remember you. I don't know who you were to me before. I don't know if my memories will come back or if they'll stay gone forever. But I know how I feel right now. And right now I'm drawn to you. And it scares me because I don't understand why."

Liam's expression softens.

"Your body remembers even if your mind doesn't," he says quietly. "We were bonded. We were together for three years. The connection goes deeper than memory."

"So what are you saying," I ask. "That I don't have a choice. That some magical bond is controlling how I feel about you."

"No," Liam says firmly. "I'm saying your instincts are telling you the truth. That I'm not a stranger even if you don't remember. But everything you feel, everything you decide, that's still your choice. I'm not forcing anything."

I look at him standing in his empty cabin and I make a decision.

"You can stay in Willowbrook," I say.

Relief floods his face.

"But I need you to understand something," I continue. "I might never remember. My memories might not come back. And even if they do, I might not want the life I had before. I might not want to go back to Frost Peak or whatever my life was there. So if you're staying because you think you're going to win me back and make me remember, you need to leave right now."

"I'm not staying for that," Liam says. "I'm staying because I want to know who you are right now. I'm staying because you make me want to be better. I'm staying because I can't imagine being anywhere else."

He steps closer and I don't move away.

"If you never remember," he says, "that's okay. Because I'm falling in love with you all over again. Not with the Luna you were. Not with the memories you lost. But with Emma Carter who works at a bakery and laughs at bad jokes and saves every stray animal she finds."

My heart is pounding.

"Don't say things like that," I whisper.

"Why not," he asks. "If it's true."

"Because it complicates everything," I say. "It makes this harder."

"I know," he says. "But I'm done hiding how I feel. You deserve to know that I'm here because I choose to be. Every single day I choose to be near you. Even though it means watching you not remember me. Even though it means respecting your boundaries when I want to pull you close. I choose you. Not because of a bond. Because of who you are."

I'm shaking now. Not from cold but from emotion. From the weight of what he's saying.

"I need time," I say.

"Take all the time you need," Liam says.

"I need to figure out my own feelings without the pressure of yours."

"I know."

"I need to know that you're here for me and not for some version of me that doesn't exist anymore."

"I am," he says simply.

I turn to leave and at the door I pause.

"If you stay," I say, "we do this right. We get to know each other like normal people. No more orchestrated moments. No more hidden agendas. Just honesty."

"Just honesty," Liam repeats.

I open the door and the cold air hits me.

"Emma," he calls. I turn back. "For what it's worth, I'm sorry for following you. And I'm grateful you're giving me a chance."

I nod because I can't trust my voice.

As I walk back through the snow toward Grace's cabin, I realize something that changes everything.

For the first time since waking up in that hospital bed, I'm not running away from my past.

I'm running toward my future.

And somehow Liam Hayes is at the center of it.

More Chapters