Chapter 15: The Pineapple Precedent — Part 1
The pineapple was on fire.
Not a small fire, either. This was a fully engulfed tropical fruit sitting in front of a downtown bakery at 8 AM, flames licking upward while the owner — a woman in her fifties named Rosa Delgado — watched with the particular expression of someone who'd reached the end of her patience.
"This is the third one this week," she told me. "The first two weren't burning. Just pineapples. Left outside my door like some kind of... produce-based threat."
"Did you report the previous incidents?"
"I reported them to the police. They said it was 'probably a prank' and to call if anything escalated." She gestured at the flaming fruit. "This feels escalated."
Gus was photographing the scene from multiple angles while I surveyed the surrounding area. The bakery occupied a corner lot on State Street, well-positioned for foot traffic and — unfortunately — easy access for anyone wanting to leave anonymous burning pineapples.
[CASE INITIATED: PINEAPPLE ARSON SERIES][META-KNOWLEDGE STATUS: UNAVAILABLE][SYSTEM NOTE: YOU'RE ON YOUR OWN. TRY NOT TO PANIC.]
I read the notification twice to make sure I understood it correctly.
"No meta-knowledge. This case doesn't exist in the show."
The realization hit harder than it should have. For three weeks, I'd been operating with a safety net — even when I avoided using it, the knowledge was there. I could always fall back on episode memories if my real detective work failed.
But this case had no episode. No spoilers. No cheat codes.
For the first time since waking up in Santa Barbara, I was going to have to be an actual detective.
"Mrs. Delgado, how long have you owned this bakery?"
"Six months. I bought it from the previous owner when he retired."
"And the pineapple incidents started..."
"Two weeks ago. Right after I put up the new sign."
The sign above the bakery door read "Delgado's Pastries — Under New Management." Fresh paint, crisp lettering, the particular optimism of a new business owner making the space her own.
[SHAWN VISION ACTIVATING — MANUAL TRIGGER]
Three highlights appeared. The "Under New Management" sign, which the system apparently considered significant. A scorch mark pattern on the sidewalk that suggested the pineapple had been placed deliberately rather than thrown. And something in the gutter near the street — a small piece of paper that had been stepped on but not destroyed.
I retrieved the paper fragment. A receipt, partially legible. "...ardware — Accelerant — $12.99..."
"Gus." I handed him the receipt. "Can you identify this?"
He examined it with the particular focus of someone who'd spent years working with chemical compounds. "Commercial fire starter. The kind they sell at hardware stores for camping and fireplaces. This brand is available at three retailers in the Santa Barbara area."
"Can you track down which stores sold this specific type recently?"
"I can make some calls." He was already pulling out his phone. "My pharmaceutical distributor contacts know people at various retail chains. Give me an hour."
"Gus's actual skills. Not meta-knowledge, not system prompts — his real professional network being useful in ways the show only hinted at."
I spent that hour canvassing the surrounding businesses.
Two more had received pineapple "gifts" in the past two weeks — a dry cleaner and a small accounting firm. Neither had reported the incidents because, like Rosa Delgado's first pineapples, they seemed like pranks rather than threats.
All three businesses had one thing in common: "Under New Management" signs. All three had changed ownership within the past six months.
[PATTERN IDENTIFIED: RECENTLY ACQUIRED BUSINESSES][INSUFFICIENT DATA FOR CONCLUSIVE ANALYSIS]
I was standing outside the accounting firm, photographing their sign, when Buzz McNab appeared with a tablet in hand.
"Got your message about checking patrol reports." He scrolled through the display. "Four more businesses received pineapple arrangements in the past two weeks. None burning, all unreported because they seemed harmless. Want the addresses?"
"Please."
He rattled them off while I wrote them on the back of a receipt. Seven businesses total. All recently acquired. All targeted with increasingly aggressive pineapple-based vandalism.
"One more thing." Buzz pulled up another file. "I ran the acquisition records like you asked. All seven businesses were purchased through the same holding company."
"What's the holding company?"
"Coastal Properties LLC. Registered agent is..." He paused, checking the screen. "Garrett Baxter Development."
The name hit me like a physical force.
"Not a coincidence. Not a pattern that might reveal itself later. A direct connection to the thread I've been tracking since the storage unit."
"Buzz, I need everything you can find on Garrett Baxter Development. Public records, property acquisitions, anything that's legally accessible without a warrant."
"This is connected to the haunted house case?"
"This is connected to everything."
The Psych office corkboard was getting crowded.
I'd pinned seven business addresses in a circle around Baxter Development's name. Red thread connected them — actual red thread, because I'd found a ball of it in Shawn's desk drawer and the visual metaphor felt appropriate.
Gus returned with purchase records from two of the three hardware stores. "The accelerant was bought with cash, no ID required. But the clerk at the second store remembers the buyer — man in his thirties, seemed agitated, paid in crumpled bills."
"Description?"
"Average height, dark hair, 'intense' according to the clerk." Gus set down his notes. "Not much to go on."
"It's something." I added the description to the corkboard. "Someone is angry at businesses owned by Garrett Baxter's holding company. Angry enough to leave burning pineapples as warnings."
"Why pineapples?"
The question stopped me. I'd been so focused on the Baxter connection that I hadn't considered the symbolic choice.
Pineapples. The fruit that represented hospitality, welcome, good fortune. The fruit that Shawn Spencer was obsessed with, that appeared hidden in every episode of the show, that had become the unofficial mascot of Psych itself.
Someone was using the symbol of welcome to send a message about unwelcome arrivals.
"The pineapple is deliberate," I said slowly. "It means something to the person doing this. Hospitality. Welcome. The opposite of what they feel about these new business owners."
[DEDUCTION LOGGED: SYMBOLIC ANALYSIS][+8 XP. NICE WORK WITHOUT A SCRIPT.]
Gus was watching me with an expression I couldn't quite read. "You're really into this case."
"It's the first one I don't have any psychic impressions about." The lie felt thin, but it was the best I could offer. "I'm having to work through it like a normal detective would."
"Is that bad?"
"It's different." I stared at the corkboard, at the web of connections that led back to Garrett Baxter. "But different isn't always bad."
The phone rang. I answered on the second ring.
"Psych, psychic detective agency, how can we help your—"
"Mr. Spencer." The voice on the other end was professional, female, and carrying the particular tone of someone reading from a schedule. "This is Sarah Chen, executive assistant to Garrett Baxter. Mr. Baxter understands you've been asking questions about his development company."
My hand tightened on the receiver. "I'm investigating a series of vandalism incidents. His company's name came up in the property records."
"Mr. Baxter is aware of the incidents and would like to speak with you directly. He has an opening tomorrow at 10 AM. Would that work for your schedule?"
I looked at Gus, who was making frantic "what's happening" gestures. I looked at the corkboard, where Baxter's name sat at the center of seven red threads.
"Tell Mr. Baxter I'll be there."
"Excellent. The office is downtown, on Anacapa Street. I'll email the address to your agency."
The line went dead.
Gus was staring at me. "Did Garrett Baxter just invite you to his office?"
"He did."
"The man you've been investigating for weeks? The one whose name keeps appearing in your cases? That Garrett Baxter?"
"Same one."
"And you said yes?"
I set down the phone and turned back to the corkboard. Seven businesses. Burning pineapples. A development company at the center of a web I couldn't see the edges of.
"I said yes because someone is targeting his properties and he wants to know who. I said yes because this case doesn't have a solution in any book I've read. And I said yes because the only way to understand what's happening is to meet the man at the center of it."
[BCM UPDATE: 39/100. +2 FROM DRAMATIC PARTNERSHIP MOMENT.]
Gus shook his head slowly. "You're walking into something you don't understand."
"I know." I traced one of the red threads with my finger, following it from a business address to Baxter's name. "But understanding is what detectives do. And right now, I'm the only kind of detective this case is going to get."
The corkboard stared back at me. Seven addresses. One name. And somewhere in Santa Barbara, a person angry enough to set pineapples on fire.
Tomorrow, I would meet Garrett Baxter.
Tonight, I needed to figure out what questions to ask.
Get Early Access to New Chapters
Thank you for reading. For those who want to skip the wait, my Patreon is currently 21 chapters ahead of the public sites.
Schedule: 7 new chapters released every 10 days.
Benefit: Gain a significant lead of 7 to 21 chapters depending on your tier.
Support the project and start reading the next arc now: Patreon.com/IsekaiStories