Chapter 23: THE BLACK ROCK
The jungle swallowed us whole.
Six of us on the expedition—Jack leading because he couldn't imagine anyone else doing it, Locke navigating because the Island whispered directions in his ear, Kate and Hurley because they volunteered, Arzt because he claimed to know explosives, and me because Locke had specifically requested my presence.
Arzt dies here, in the original timeline. Unstable dynamite, careless handling, a moment of hubris followed by sudden violent ending.
I positioned myself near him as we walked, watching for the warning signs I remembered from the episode. The nervous energy. The overconfidence. The need to prove expertise that didn't quite match reality.
"The thing about old explosives," Arzt was explaining to anyone who'd listen, "is that they become more volatile with age. Nitroglycerin sweating out of the sticks, crystal formations in the—"
"Watch your step."
My hand caught his arm, pulling him back from a root that would have sent him sprawling. He looked at me with surprise and irritation in equal measure.
"I can see where I'm walking, Sawyer."
"Didn't look like it."
"Maybe mind your own business."
Fine. But when we reach the dynamite, you're staying outside the hold.
The terrain climbed. Rousseau's maps showed the Black Rock in the dark territory—the region where the Monster hunted most frequently, where survivors who wandered too deep rarely returned. I led us around the worst of it, choosing paths that avoided the killing grounds without appearing to know they existed.
Locke noticed.
"You navigate like you've walked these trails before."
"I pay attention to the terrain."
"You pay attention to things that haven't happened yet." His voice was quiet, pitched for my ears only. "The way you avoided that clearing two miles back. The way you steered us around the eastern ridge. Those were specific choices, not general caution."
"Call it instinct."
"I call it something else." His smile held no warmth. "The Island speaks to those who listen. I've been hearing it since the crash. I thought I was alone."
"You are alone."
"Am I?"
The question hung between us as the jungle opened into a clearing, and the Black Rock emerged from the vegetation like a fever dream made solid.
---
The ship was impossible.
A nineteenth-century sailing vessel, three-masted, easily two hundred feet long—sitting in the middle of a jungle, miles from any coast, trees growing through its deck like it had been there for centuries.
"How?" Hurley's voice carried the appropriate awe. "How does a ship end up in the middle of the jungle?"
A tidal wave. A supernatural force. The Island's way of collecting things it finds useful.
"Doesn't matter how," Jack said. "What matters is whether there's anything useful inside."
We approached cautiously. The hull was weathered but intact, barnacles still visible beneath layers of moss and lichen. I touched the wood—
And flinched as Ancestral Memory tried to trigger.
Not a full download, not like Locke or Claire. Just fragments. Screaming. Chains rattling in darkness. The smell of blood and salt and human desperation. Something terrible had happened inside this ship, something that left echoes even centuries later.
"You okay?" Kate appeared at my shoulder.
"Fine. Just... old wood." I pulled my hand back, shaking off the phantom sensations. "Let's find the dynamite and get out."
The hold was exactly as I remembered from the show—dark, cramped, filled with crates and chains and the bones of men who'd never reached their destination. Arzt pushed forward eagerly, his flashlight sweeping across deteriorating cargo.
"There. Those crates. See the markings? That's industrial explosive, nineteenth-century manufacture."
"Everyone back up." My voice came out sharper than intended. "Nobody touches anything until we know what we're dealing with."
"I know what we're dealing with," Arzt said irritably. "I've handled explosives before. You just need to—"
"You need to stay back." I positioned myself between him and the crates. "Nitroglycerin that old isn't just unstable—it's unpredictable. The slightest vibration, the wrong angle of pressure, and we all become a cautionary tale."
"Sawyer's right." Jack moved up beside me, examining the crates without touching them. "We do this carefully or we don't do it at all."
Arzt opened his mouth to argue, then closed it. Something in my expression—or maybe in Jack's—convinced him that this wasn't a negotiation.
"Fine. Tell me what to do."
We extracted six sticks of dynamite over the next two hours. Slow, methodical, treating each cylinder like the murder weapon it was. I handled most of the actual removal, hands steady despite the knowledge of what would happen if I made a single mistake.
No one died.
Arzt dies here, in the original timeline. Arzt dies because he gets careless, gets cocky, tries to demonstrate expertise he doesn't actually have.
But not today.
"That's enough," Jack said finally. "Six sticks, carefully wrapped. Let's get back to camp."
The return journey felt longer than the outward trip. The dynamite weighed nothing compared to the burden of knowing what it was meant for—blowing open a hatch that led to a button that held back something terrible.
Locke fell into step beside me as we reached the jungle's edge.
"The Island speaks to you," he said again. "I see it now."
"The Island doesn't speak. It watches."
"That's what someone who hears it would say."
His smile held the particular serenity of absolute faith. I didn't share it. The Island wasn't a god to be worshipped—it was a predator to be survived.
But I couldn't say that. Couldn't explain the difference between his mystical certainty and my desperate pragmatism.
So I said nothing, and we walked in silence toward the hatch that would change everything.
Read the raw, unfiltered story as it unfolds. Your support makes this possible!
Find it all at patreon.com/Whatif0
Timeline Viewer ($6): Get 10 chapters of early access + 5 new chapters weekly.
Timeline Explorer ($9): Jump 15-20 chapters ahead of everyone.
Timeline Keeper ($15): Get Instant Access to chapters the moment I finish writing them. No more waiting.