Chapter 36: The One with the Law School Graduation
The Columbia Law School graduation had the particular quality of an event that knew exactly what it was — serious, earned, and slightly too warm for the gowns everyone was wearing. The quad outside Jerome Greene Hall was full of the specific energy of people who had finished something large and were still deciding how to feel about that, surrounded by families who had been deciding for years and were ready to show it.
Ethan had brought Missy because Missy had asked, and because Mary Cooper's approach to her daughter's first full day in New York was to say yes to everything that seemed safe and interesting, and Columbia's campus on graduation day was both.
Missy had been in the city for forty-eight hours and had already formed strong opinions about the subway, the pizza on the corner near Sheldon's building, and the specific quality of New York light in the morning, which she'd described as different from Texas light in a way she couldn't fully explain but felt certain about.
She was wearing a dress she'd bought the previous afternoon on Columbus Avenue with the decisive speed of someone who knew what she wanted when she saw it, and she had the easy, open quality she always had — the version of the Cooper family warmth that didn't require processing time before deployment.
Sheldon had declined to come.
"I've been to a graduation," Sheldon had said, when asked.
"When?" Ethan had said.
"My own," Sheldon had said. "East Texas Tech, age fourteen. The experience did not improve upon reflection."
Leonard had come.
This surprised Ethan slightly — Leonard was still in the early phase of learning what New York offered and had not yet developed strong opinions about which of it to seek out. But he'd come down from the building when they were leaving, hands in his jacket pockets, with the expression of someone who had decided that being outside was better than the alternative, which was being inside with Sheldon's ongoing reorganization of their shared bookshelf system.
"What are we doing?" Leonard had asked.
"Columbia Law graduation," Ethan had said. "Missy wants to see the campus dressed up."
Leonard had looked at Missy, who had given him the specific Missy smile that communicated she was completely aware of the effect it had and had made a considered decision to deploy it.
"Sure," Leonard had said.
The family was near the east side of the quad, slightly apart from the main crowd, in the process of taking photographs with the focused inefficiency of a group where everyone had an opinion about the framing. There were five of them — a tall silver-haired man with the bearing of someone accustomed to being the most certain person in any room, a woman in her early thirties who was visibly pregnant and managing the situation with the competence of someone for whom competence was a baseline rather than an achievement, a man beside her with the open, slightly hopeful expression of someone perpetually optimistic about how things were going to go, a teenage girl who was somewhere between bored and interested depending on the moment, and a young man in his law school graduation gown who was attempting to get everyone to look at the camera simultaneously and was losing.
The young man — mid-twenties, red-haired, with the expression of someone who had just finished three years of law school and was entitled to look pleased about it — caught Ethan's eye with the universal expression of a person who needed help with a photograph.
Ethan crossed the quad.
"Need a hand?" he said.
The relief on the law school graduate's face was immediate. "Please," he said. "My family has strong individual opinions about photography."
"I've noticed," Ethan said, which was diplomatically accurate.
He took the camera — a decent 35mm, the kind of camera that suggested someone in the family took photographs seriously — and looked through the viewfinder at the assembled group.
"Okay," Ethan said. "Everyone toward the center. The light's better from this angle."
The silver-haired man moved immediately, with the efficiency of someone used to instructions that made structural sense. The pregnant woman moved with the careful deliberateness of someone at approximately seven months who had made a working peace with her own center of gravity. Her husband moved in the cheerful, slightly too-large way of a man who always occupied more space than strictly necessary. The teenager moved with the particular teenage energy of someone doing something for other people and making sure everyone knew it was for other people.
The law school graduate stood in the middle and looked at the camera with the expression he'd probably been planning since the first week of law school.
Ethan took three photos. Two of them were going to be good.
"Mitchell Pritchett," the graduate said, extending his hand afterward. "Columbia Law, class of '95. Environmental law concentration."
"Ethan Burke," Ethan said. "Columbia Biology, PhD candidate." He gestured. "Missy Cooper, visiting from Galveston. Leonard Hofstadter, Physics."
Mitchell looked at Leonard. "Caltech?"
"Originally," Leonard said, with the expression he always had when people made this accurate inference.
"I had a friend at Caltech," Mitchell said. "He described it as — and I'm quoting — 'intellectually stimulating and socially barren.'"
"That's about right," Leonard said.
The pregnant woman had arrived beside Mitchell with the quiet efficiency of someone who had been listening and was ready to participate. "Claire Dunphy," she said. "Mitchell's sister. Don't let him be the only one who introduces himself — he's been waiting to say 'Columbia Law, class of '95' to strangers all morning and he needs the moment diluted."
"I have not been—" Mitchell started.
"You practiced it in the hotel mirror," Claire said pleasantly.
Mitchell looked at Ethan with the expression of a man choosing not to confirm or deny something in front of a stranger.
"You look amazing," Missy said to Claire, with the complete sincerity she brought to things she meant, which was most things. "I mean, you're about to have a baby and you're here doing all of this."
Claire looked at Missy with the slightly surprised warmth of someone receiving a compliment that landed genuinely. "Thank you," she said. "This one—" she gestured at herself "—was not planned for graduation weekend, but here we are."
"Haley and then this one," the man beside her said, appearing at her shoulder with the timing of someone who had been listening from two feet away and had been waiting for his entrance. "Phil Dunphy. Real estate. I've sold three houses this year." He said this with the complete conviction of a man who considered this information relevant to any conversation.
"Good market for it," Ethan said.
"Incredible market," Phil said. "You wouldn't believe what's happening in the suburbs right now. If you ever need—"
"Phil," Claire said.
"I'm just saying," Phil said. "New friends are potential clients. That's not a philosophy, that's math."
The silver-haired man had arrived at the edge of the group with the specific quality of a man who had been watching all of this and was deciding whether to engage. He had the slightly compressed expression of someone for whom enthusiasm required effort.
"Jay Pritchett," he said. "Mitchell's father. Claire's father." He looked at Phil. "Phil's father-in-law."
The specific weight he put on the last description communicated an entire relationship history.
Phil's smile remained at full deployment. "Jay and I have a great relationship," he said, to Ethan and Leonard and Missy, none of whom had asked.
"Sure," Jay said.
The teenager — Haley, who was perhaps four or five and had apparently reached the exact limit of how long a person that age could be expected to participate in an adult conversation — had found Missy with the unerring instinct of someone locating the most interesting available option.
Missy had crouched down to Haley's level with the easy naturalness of someone from a large family for whom this adjustment was automatic. They were having what appeared to be a serious conversation about something, conducted at a volume that didn't carry.
Leonard watched this with the expression he had when he was observing something that surprised him in a good way.
"She's good with kids," Leonard said, to Ethan.
"She's good with people," Ethan said. "Kids just respond faster."
"Sheldon isn't good with people," Leonard said.
"Sheldon's good with specific people," Ethan said. "The category is smaller but the quality is high."
Leonard considered this. "That's a generous framing."
"It's the accurate one," Ethan said.
Mitchell had come to stand with them, in the way people sometimes did at these events — gravitating toward people who seemed to have a reasonable relationship with conversation.
"Environmental law," Ethan said. "What direction?"
"Conservation," Mitchell said. "Land use, endangered species protections, the intersection with property rights." He paused. "It's not the most commercially lucrative direction."
"Your father's opinion?" Ethan said.
Mitchell looked at him with the expression of someone correctly identified. "My father built a closet company," he said. "He has a specific framework for what constitutes a practical career."
"And environmental law doesn't fit the framework," Ethan said.
"Environmental law," Mitchell said carefully, "is not not fitting the framework. It's actively challenging the framework's foundational assumptions."
"That sounds like something you've said to him," Ethan said.
"Several times," Mitchell said. "With variable results."
Jay had drifted close enough to be in the conversation without having announced himself, which was, Ethan suspected, a habitual mode of operation.
"The results vary," Jay said, "because I keep having to point out that the electricity in his apartment also comes from somewhere, and that somewhere is usually a power plant that his clients are suing."
"That's not—" Mitchell started.
"I'm not saying it's wrong," Jay said. "I'm saying it's complicated. There's a difference."
Mitchell looked at his father with the expression of a son who had been having a version of this conversation his whole life and had not yet arrived at the definitive version of it.
"He's proud of you," Claire said, appearing from somewhere. "He just expresses it in the form of devil's advocate positions."
"I'm standing right here," Jay said.
"I know," Claire said. "I said it to his face on purpose. It's more efficient."
Jay looked at Ethan with the expression of a man who had raised this person and was not entirely sure how.
"She's been doing that since she was eleven," Jay said.
"It works though," Phil offered.
Jay looked at Phil.
Phil looked at the camera he was now holding.
"Great photos," Phil said, to no one in particular.
The teenage daughter had graduated from the serious conversation with Missy to riding on Phil's shoulders, which Phil was facilitating with the cheerful physical willingness of a man who had apparently decided that his back situation was a future-Phil problem.
Leonard, who had been talking to Mitchell for the last ten minutes about something involving water rights legislation and whether current environmental frameworks could accommodate the regulatory implications of genetic technology — which was, Ethan noted, a more specific conversation than most people had at graduation ceremonies — had the expression of someone who had found an unexpected point of genuine interest.
"You should talk to people in the Biology department," Leonard said to Mitchell. "Specifically about the downstream legal frameworks for genetic modification in agriculture. Nobody's thinking about it yet."
"That's the thing about environmental law," Mitchell said. "By the time everyone's thinking about it, you've already missed the window to shape the framework."
"Ethan's doing work in that space," Leonard said.
Mitchell looked at Ethan. "The microplastics work?"
"You've heard of it?" Ethan said.
"Leonard mentioned it," Mitchell said. "The framing stuck with me. Defining the problem before the problem has consensus." He paused. "That's exactly how environmental litigation works. The cases that matter are the ones where someone saw the problem coming and built the legal argument before the damage was visible."
Ethan looked at him. This was a more substantive conversation than he'd expected from a graduation photo encounter.
"When you pass the bar," Ethan said, "I'd like to buy you a coffee and talk about regulatory frameworks for genetic technology."
Mitchell looked at him with the slightly surprised expression of someone being taken seriously in a field they'd just entered. "I'd like that," he said.
Ethan reached into his jacket pocket and found a business card — the Columbia Biology department card with his extension, which he kept specifically for these moments. He handed it to Mitchell.
Mitchell looked at it. Then he produced his own — newly printed, the ink still feeling fresh, Mitchell Pritchett, J.D., Columbia Law School, with a San Francisco address below.
"San Francisco?" Ethan said.
"That's where we're based," Mitchell said, with the slight expression of someone who had made a decision and was comfortable with it. "I have a position with an environmental firm there starting in August."
"Good city for it," Ethan said.
"My dad thinks I should be in New York," Mitchell said.
"Where does your dad think you should be?" Ethan said.
Mitchell smiled — the real one, the one that wasn't managing anything. "Somewhere with a clearer ROI," he said.
Jay, who was close enough to have heard this, made a sound that was not quite a laugh and not quite disagreement but landed somewhere between the two that communicated: fair point, kid.
Missy found Ethan when they were leaving, falling into step beside him with the easy companionship she brought to movement.
"The pregnant woman," Missy said. "Claire. She asked me if I was nervous about college."
"What did you say?" Ethan said.
"I said not really," Missy said. "Which is mostly true." She was quiet for a moment. "She said she was nervous about everything when she was my age, and then she had kids young and got through it, and it turned out she was better at the hard things than the easy things."
"That's a real observation," Ethan said.
"She seems like someone who's figured out what she's actually good at," Missy said. "Not what she thought she'd be good at. The actual thing."
Ethan looked at her. Missy Cooper was seventeen and had been listening to conversations her whole life in the shadow of a brother who dominated rooms, and she had developed, in that shadow, a quality of attention that was its own kind of intelligence.
"You're going to be good at things too," Ethan said. "The actual things. When you find them."
"I know," Missy said, without self-consciousness. "I just haven't decided what they are yet."
"That's the right place to be at seventeen," Ethan said.
"Sheldon decided at three," Missy said.
"Sheldon is one data point," Ethan said. "Not a baseline."
Missy laughed — the full Cooper laugh, the one that had the warmth in it. "Don't tell him that," she said.
"I won't," Ethan said. "He'd want to argue about sample sizes."
Leonard was quieter than usual on the walk back, which Ethan registered and didn't push. He had the expression of someone who had had a good day and was still inside it.
At the corner of Broadway and 116th, Leonard stopped.
"Mitchell's going to be good at his job," Leonard said.
"I think so," Ethan said.
"He knows what it's for," Leonard said. "The work. He knows why he's doing it." He looked at the campus entrance. "I'm still figuring out what mine is for."
"That's what being here is for," Ethan said. "Not just the physics. The figuring out."
Leonard looked at him. "Did it take you long?"
"Still going," Ethan said. "The dissertation was one answer. The script is a different answer. I don't think you arrive at one answer and stop."
"My mother thinks you do," Leonard said.
"Your mother's answer is very good for your mother," Ethan said carefully. "It might also be good for you. The question is whether it's the whole answer or just part of it."
Leonard was quiet for a moment, with the expression of someone sitting with something rather than resolving it.
"Okay," he said. "Yeah."
They walked on, the campus settling into its post-graduation afternoon quiet, the gowns slowly disappearing from the quad, the families with their photographs heading toward dinners and hotels and the particular satisfied exhaustion of a day that had meant something.
Back at the building, Mary and Beverly were in the common room.
Mary had been shopping — there were bags from the grocery store on the table and the particular organized spread of someone who had identified a kitchen and decided to use it. The smell of something already in the oven had reached the hallway.
Beverly was at the table with a legal pad, writing something with the focused efficiency she brought to everything, and she looked up when they came through the door with the assessment-immediate quality of her attention.
"How was the campus?" Mary said.
"Good," Missy said. "We met a law school graduate. He's going to San Francisco to do environmental law."
"That's a difficult field," Beverly said.
"He knows that," Missy said. "He's doing it anyway."
Beverly looked at her for a moment. "That's either admirable or impractical," she said. "Sometimes both."
"Usually both," Ethan said. "In my experience."
Mary was already distributing things from the grocery bags with the comfortable authority of a woman who had decided that whatever space she was in was going to be taken care of. She set something on the counter for Sheldon — specific crackers, a particular arrangement — with the precise knowledge of a parent who had been paying attention for fifteen years.
"Sheldon's been in his room," she said. "He said he's been thinking about something."
"The epistemology conversation," Ethan said.
Mary looked at him. "What epistemology conversation?"
"Phoebe said something to him yesterday about documentation and truth," Ethan said. "He said he needed to think about it."
Mary had the expression she wore when Sheldon had been affected by something and she was deciding how to receive that information. "He doesn't usually need to think about things," she said. "He usually just—"
"Concludes," Leonard said, from the doorway.
"Concludes," Mary agreed.
"This is different," Ethan said. "This one doesn't conclude easily. That's why it's worth thinking about."
Mary looked at the hallway that led to Sheldon's room, with the expression of a mother who knew her child and was revising something in what she knew.
Beverly, at the table, had stopped writing. She was looking at Ethan with the clinical attention she brought to things that interested her.
"The Buffay woman," she said.
"Phoebe," Ethan said.
"She gave a fifteen-year-old physicist a genuinely difficult epistemological question through the medium of a song about arguing," Beverly said. "And he's been processing it for twenty-four hours."
"Yes," Ethan said.
Beverly picked up her pen. "Interesting," she said, which from Beverly Hofstadter was the equivalent of a standing ovation.
Leonard looked at Ethan with the expression he'd had at Central Perk, the one that said these are not ordinary people.
"No," Ethan confirmed, answering the unasked question. "They're really not."
Sheldon emerged from his room at six, with the expression of a man who had reached a conclusion and was prepared to deliver it.
He stood in the doorway of the common room, looked at the assembled people — Mary, Beverly, Missy, Leonard, Ethan — and said: "I've been thinking about what Phoebe said."
The room gave him the space for it.
"The argument was that things can be true before they're documented," Sheldon said. "Which I initially dismissed because it conflates ontological status with epistemic status. A thing's existence is separate from our knowledge of it." He paused. "However."
Everyone waited.
"The question of whether something is true versus whether it exists is not trivial," Sheldon said. "Truth is a property we assign. Existence precedes the assignment. So if truth requires documentation, then Phoebe's position — while imprecisely stated — is pointing at something real about the relationship between discovery and truth-assignment." He looked at the room. "She was right about the direction. The vocabulary was incorrect."
Beverly set down her pen entirely. "He's been working on that for twenty-four hours?" she said, to Ethan.
"Since yesterday afternoon," Ethan confirmed.
"That's—" Beverly paused. "That's a non-trivial philosophical distinction for a fifteen-year-old."
"He's Sheldon," Ethan said.
"I know who he is," Beverly said. "I'm noting that he arrived at it through a song." She looked at her legal pad. "I need to talk to the Buffay woman."
"She's at Central Perk most mornings," Ethan said.
Mary was looking at Sheldon with the expression she had when her son did something that reminded her, after all the familiar daily extraordinary, that he was still doing something she couldn't fully see the edges of.
"Moonpie," she said.
"I prefer Sheldon," Sheldon said.
"I know you do," she said.
Missy reached over and pushed Sheldon's shoulder once, briefly, the sibling version of a hug. He tolerated this with the expression of a man accepting something he had long since categorized as inevitable.
"Don't tell Phoebe he's been thinking about it for a day," Missy said, to Ethan.
"Why not?" Ethan said.
"Because then she'll write a song about it," Missy said. "And then he'll have to think about that one too."
Leonard laughed — the real one, surprised out of him, the one that meant he'd stopped managing something.
Sheldon looked at Leonard. Then at Missy. Then at the middle distance, with the expression of someone calculating whether Missy's prediction was accurate.
"She probably would," he said.
"She definitely would," Ethan said.
Sheldon sat down at the table with the resignation of a man who had accepted his situation and was choosing to be present in it. Mary put food in front of him — the right crackers, the specific arrangement — and he ate without comment, which was Sheldon's version of thank you.
Outside, the spring evening was doing what spring evenings did when the city was finally fully in them — the light going gold through the windows, the campus quiet now, the families dispersed to their dinners and their hotels and their particular versions of the day.
Inside the common room, Beverly Hofstadter was writing something on her legal pad that had shifted in direction from whatever it had been before, and Mary Cooper was making tea for six people without asking if anyone wanted tea because she already knew, and Missy was telling Leonard about the conversation with Claire with the animated ease of someone who had been paying attention and was ready to share it, and Leonard was listening in the way he listened when something was actually interesting to him.
Ethan sat back and looked at the room.
All of these people, arriving from their different directions, finding their way into the same space.
Good enough, he thought.
More than good enough.
[Reader Support Milestones]
500 Power Stones → +1 Chapter
10 Reviews → +1 Chapter
Enjoyed the read? Leave a review.
20+advanced chapters on P1treon Soulforger