Cherreads

Chapter 9 - Chapter 9: The One Where They Don't Read the Reviews

Chapter 9: The One Where They Don't Read the Reviews

The Geller house in Long Island had the particular quality of a home that had absorbed thirty years of family life and wasn't shy about it. Every surface held something — photographs in frames that had never been updated, a bowl of hard candy that had probably been there since the Reagan administration, the specific smell of a house where someone had cooked a great many meals with a great deal of intention.

The funeral had been that morning. Quiet, dignified, the kind of service that did exactly what it was supposed to do — gave people somewhere to put the feeling, gave them something to stand around and do together. Mrs. Geller's mother had been eighty-three, had lived a full and specific life, and the eulogies had reflected that: funny in the right places, true throughout.

Now it was the reception, and the house was full of the particular organized chaos of post-funeral gatherings — too much food, not enough places to sit, relatives who only existed at these events appearing from somewhere and then disappearing again.

Joey had been doing well for the first hour and a half.

Ethan found him in the hallway near the coat closet, which was slightly removed from the main gathering, holding a small transistor radio approximately two inches from his ear with the focused expression of a man trying to listen to something without technically listening to something.

"Joey."

Joey looked up. "The game starts in ten minutes," he said, quietly but without particular guilt. "I just want to know the score. I'm not going to make a whole thing of it."

"You're at a funeral reception."

"I'm at a post-funeral reception," Joey said. "The funeral part is over. This is more of a party."

"It's not a party."

"There's a cheese plate," Joey said. "That's party infrastructure."

Ethan opened his mouth to respond, and then Jack Geller materialized from the living room, passing through the hallway with a plate of something and the slightly unfocused expression of a man who had been talking to relatives for two hours and was approaching his limit.

He saw the radio.

Something shifted in his expression — not disapproval exactly. More like recognition.

"Who's playing?" Jack asked quietly.

"Giants and Eagles," Joey said. "Kickoff in eight minutes."

Jack glanced toward the living room, where Judy Geller was holding court over a group of aunts. He looked at the radio. He looked at Joey.

"I'll get us some of that cheese," Jack said, and settled against the wall next to Joey with the comfortable decisiveness of a man who had made a decision and was at peace with it.

Ethan looked at both of them for a moment.

"I was never here," he said, and kept walking.

Chandler was standing near the fireplace with the expression he wore when something was bothering him and he'd been carrying it long enough that it had started to show.

Ethan stopped next to him. "You've got a face."

"I always have a face," Chandler said. "It came with the head."

"A specific face."

Chandler was quiet for a moment, looking at the middle distance. "Do I give off a vibe?"

Ethan waited.

"My coworker," Chandler said. "The one who wanted to set me up. She said it again today. That she gets a certain — that I have a certain quality." He said the word like it was something he'd found in his pocket and wasn't sure what to do with. "And now I can't stop thinking about whether other people think the same thing, and whether that means something, and I don't — I genuinely don't know what to do with it."

Ethan looked at him for a moment. "There's a woman over by the window," he said. "Dark coat, talking to Mrs. Geller's sister. She's been standing there for twenty minutes and I don't think she knows anyone here well enough to be enjoying it."

Chandler looked. "Okay."

"Go talk to her."

"Why?"

"Because you've been standing here thinking about what other people think of you, and the fastest way to stop doing that is to have an actual conversation with an actual person and remember that the real version of you is more interesting than the version you're worried about."

Chandler considered this with the expression of a man who suspected he was being given advice disguised as a social nudge. "That's either very wise or a very elaborate way of getting me to talk to someone at a funeral."

"Both can be true," Ethan said.

Chandler went.

Ethan watched him cross the room, watched the woman turn, watched the particular moment of two people deciding whether a conversation was going to happen. It happened.

About fifteen minutes later, Chandler came back with a slightly different expression — less like a man carrying something, more like a man who had set it down temporarily.

"Her name's Andrea," he said. "She's Dorothy's daughter. She's a landscape architect. We talked about the crossword puzzle she's been doing in the car and whether you can legitimately use proper nouns."

"And?" Ethan said.

"She does not appear to think I have a vibe," Chandler said, with the careful delivery of a man reporting a result he wasn't sure what to do with yet. "Or if she does, she didn't mention it."

"Good," Ethan said.

"Although," Chandler added, "I'm not entirely sure that settles anything. One data point, limited sample size—"

"Chandler."

"Right," Chandler said. "I'm getting out of my own head."

"You're getting out of your own head," Ethan confirmed.

Ross had found the Scotch about forty-five minutes into the reception, which Ethan clocked but didn't immediately intervene on, because Ross was a grown adult at his grandmother's funeral and was entitled to a drink.

Two drinks was fine.

By the third drink, Ross had the particular loosened quality of a man whose internal editor had gone off-shift, and Ethan began keeping a closer eye on him.

He was, unfortunately, across the room when it happened.

Ross found Chandler near the fireplace — Chandler had migrated back to his original position, now with more equanimity — and said, at a volume slightly above what the situation called for: "Chandler. Listen. I have to say something. If you want to be gay — if that's what's going on — you don't have to do anything differently. You just follow your heart. That's all. You follow your heart."

Chandler went very still.

The people in the immediate vicinity of the fireplace found reasons to be somewhere else, with the practiced efficiency of people who had learned to recognize a social event requiring distance.

Ethan crossed the room in about eight seconds, took Ross gently but firmly by the elbow, and steered him toward the couch in the corner.

"Okay," Ethan said, sitting him down. "Water. Now."

"I'm just being supportive," Ross said.

"I know," Ethan said. "That's the problem. Supportive Ross is great. Loud supportive Ross at a funeral is a different situation."

"Chandler should know he has people in his corner," Ross said, with the earnest conviction of a very drunk man who was genuinely trying to do something kind.

"Chandler knows," Ethan said. "He knows. I promise."

He got Ross a glass of water and sat with him for a few minutes until the Scotch settled into something more manageable. Monica appeared at some point, looked at Ross, looked at Ethan, and said "How bad?" with her eyes. Ethan made a small gesture that communicated manageable, handled, he said something to Chandler, I'll explain later. Monica absorbed this, patted Ross's knee, and went back to managing the cheese situation.

Then Ross, water in hand, slightly more coherent but still operating with the emotional safety features disengaged, looked across the room to where Rachel was talking to one of the aunts.

"She's great," he said quietly. "She's just — she's really great."

"Yeah," Ethan said.

"I've known her since we were kids and she's just — she keeps being great. Every version of her is great."

"Ross."

"I know," Ross said. "I know. It's not the moment."

"It's really not the moment," Ethan agreed.

Ross looked at his water glass. "But there's going to be a moment, right?"

"There's going to be a moment," Ethan said. "I'd suggest being sober for it."

"That's fair," Ross said.

Rachel caught Ethan's eye from across the room, raised an eyebrow — everything okay? Ethan gave a small nod. She accepted this and went back to the aunt.

Later, after the reception had wound down and the relatives had dispersed and Monica had organized the leftover food into labeled containers with the focused efficiency of someone who needed to do something with her hands, Ethan drove back into the city.

He stopped at the hotel on 57th just before eight.

Julia was waiting in the lobby in a dark coat, and she had the particular expression of someone who was either very calm or had decided to be, and Ethan wasn't sure which yet.

"Ready?" he said.

"Probably not," she said. "Let's go anyway."

The theater on 68th was not full. This was, Ethan felt, an understatement. There were seven other people in the auditorium when they sat down, including two who left before the opening credits finished, and one who appeared to be asleep by the end of the first act.

Julia sat with her coat in her lap and watched herself on screen with the particular focused stillness of someone doing something difficult. Ethan watched the movie and occasionally watched her watching it, which was in some ways more interesting.

She was right that her work in it was good. The movie around her was uneven — the tonal mix of romantic comedy and thriller never quite resolved, and Nick Nolte and Julia Roberts generated the specific on-screen energy of two people who had been in close proximity for too long and were now very good at being professionally courteous — but Julia herself was doing exactly what she'd described at the museum: finding the specific person, playing that, letting the rest follow.

The lights came up. The remaining five audience members filed out with the quiet disappointment of people who had paid for something and received less than expected.

Julia looked at the screen for a moment after it went dark.

"Okay," she said finally.

"Okay," Ethan agreed.

"Dinner," she said. "You're buying. You picked the movie."

"You agreed to the movie."

"Under false pretenses."

"I said it would be either a very good idea or a very uncomfortable one," Ethan said. "I was right."

"You were right about the wrong one," she said, and stood up and put on her coat, and that was that.

The restaurant was on the Upper West Side — small, warm, the kind of place that had been there for twenty years and intended to be there for twenty more. Good wine list, tables far enough apart to have an actual conversation, lighting that was doing its best work.

Julia had the red wine. Ethan had the same. The menus came and went.

"Okay," Ethan said, after a moment. "The reviews."

Julia looked at him across the table. "I've read them."

"I know. But I've curated them." He pulled a folded newspaper clipping from his jacket pocket — he'd grabbed it that afternoon, a reflex — and smoothed it on the table. "I'm going to read you the good ones."

"There are good ones?"

"There are good parts of ones," he said, which was more accurate.

He found the first passage and read it with the authority of a man delivering an official statement: "'Roberts is perfectly cast — luminous, quick-witted, entirely at home in the genre.'" He set the paper down. "That's you. That's what you do."

She tilted her head. "Continue."

"'Roberts brings an intelligence and self-possession to the role that the film around her doesn't always earn.'" He looked up. "Which is a compliment wearing a criticism's coat, but the compliment is real."

Julia's expression shifted slightly — something softening at the edges.

"'The film's best moments belong entirely to Roberts, who has clearly found the version of this character that matters and plays it with complete conviction.'" He folded the paper. "That's three. Three separate critics, three separate papers, all arriving at the same conclusion independently."

"Which is?"

"That you're doing your job and doing it well," he said. "The rest is the movie's problem, not yours."

She looked at him for a moment. Then she picked up her wine glass. "You skipped parts."

"I skipped the parts about the male lead being miscast and the tonal inconsistency and the soundtrack," he said. "None of which are your fault, all of which are being held against the film, none of which say anything about you specifically."

"Some of them say things about me specifically."

"None of the true ones do," Ethan said.

She was quiet for a moment, turning the stem of the wine glass slowly. "You know what the frustrating thing is? It's not even that the reviews are bad. It's that I know the performance was right. I could feel it while we were filming.

And then everything around it didn't come together, and now the reviews are about the whole thing, and the part that was right gets buried under everything else."

"That's the job though," Ethan said. "Right? You can only control your part of it. The rest is collaboration, and sometimes collaboration fails, and sometimes it fails in ways that are visible and public and people write articles about it."

"That's very reasonable," she said.

"I'm an unreasonably reasonable person," he said.

She laughed. "You are, actually." She set down the glass. "Tell me something else. Tell me something that isn't about the movie."

So he did. He told her about the PhD — the final stretch of it, the tenure track ambition, the microplastics research that nobody was thinking about yet but would be. He told her about the CRISPR work, about the Human Genome Project moving forward, about the conversation with Professor Aldridge where he'd said I want to be in that room when it cracks open and had meant it completely.

He told her about Jurassic Park — that he'd seen it the previous year and spent the entire second half mentally composing a list of scientific consultancy notes that nobody had asked for, and that this had led to a genuine, if informal, interest in what it would mean to have a scientist in the room during film production.

"Not on set," he said. "Or not only. But in development. When the decisions are being made. Because the difference between a film that uses science as set dressing and a film that actually gets something right is usually one person who knew enough to push back at the right moment."

Julia was watching him with the expression she'd had at the museum — genuine attention, the real thing. "You'd want to do that? Consulting work?"

"I find it interesting," he said. "The intersection. Where the accuracy matters, where it doesn't, where a small change makes something feel true versus feel like a prop."

"You should talk to people," she said. "In the industry. I know people."

"I know you do," he said.

"I mean it," she said. "People who would find that genuinely useful."

"I might take you up on that," he said. "Eventually. When the PhD is done and I've got something to actually offer."

"You already have something to offer," she said, with the directness of someone who had decided to say the true thing.

Ethan looked at her for a moment. "Thank you," he said, and meant it.

He drove her back to the hotel around eleven. The city was doing its late Saturday thing — the traffic thinning out, the lights going from full brightness to something more selective, the particular New York feeling of the night opening up into something slightly larger than the day.

She didn't get out of the car immediately when he pulled up. They sat for a moment in the particular comfortable silence of two people who had had a good evening and weren't entirely ready for it to be over.

"The casserole situation at the Geller house," Julia said eventually. "Did it resolve?"

Ethan laughed — surprised out of it. "Monica had it under control by nine. She always does."

"She sounds formidable."

"She's the most competent person I know," Ethan said. "And I know some genuinely impressive people."

Julia smiled. She looked out through the windshield at the hotel entrance for a moment — the doorman, the lit lobby, the revolving door doing its slow rotation.

"This was a good day," she said. "The museum. The absolutely empty movie theater. The curated reviews." She looked at him. "You made a bad movie night into a good one."

"The bar was low," he said.

"The bar was fine," she said. "You cleared it by a lot."

She opened the door, and then paused, looking back at him with the expression she'd had at the museum and in the café and across the dinner table — something curious and open and not entirely finished.

"Next time," she said, "I pick the movie."

"That's more than fair," he said.

She smiled — the real one, the big one — and got out of the car, and went through the revolving door, and Ethan sat there for a moment in the quiet of the car, the city doing its thing around him, and thought: yeah, this was a good day.

He drove home through the lit streets, the radio on low, the night doing what New York nights do — holding everything at once and making it feel, somehow, like enough.

[500 PS unlocks 1 Extra Chapter]

[10 Reviews unlock 1 Extra Chapter]

Thanks for reading—reviews are appreciated.

P1treon Soulforger has 20+advance chapters

More Chapters