Kaplan's office door was open.
She was standing at her desk when he came in, not sitting — which he'd learned meant she had something she'd been handling repeatedly, turning over, waiting to show someone. The folder was already on top of the stack, centered, facing outward.
"Close the door," she said.
He did.
"Sit."
He sat across from her desk, and she picked up the folder and held it with both hands the way people held things they were genuinely excited about but trying not to show how much. Kaplan's default register was sharp and professional, but she had a tell when she'd found something significant: a fractional stillness, the kind of stillness that came before she let herself move.
"The restricted archive on sub-level two," she said. "Colonial-era Dutch records, donated by a private collection in 1987. They've been catalogued but not fully translated. I've been working through the 1720s material because your sourcing for the Pale Rider chapt er pointed at a gap in the land record sequence I wanted to understand."
She opened the folder and laid it on the desk between them.
A photocopy of a land deed. Original in Dutch, dense script, the colonial abbreviations that made period Dutch almost a separate language from modern. At the top: a date in the format of the period, which Mythic Tongue translated without him having to think about it. 1726. At the bottom: two signatures and a settlement seal.
He made himself read it at the pace of someone working through a translation rather than someone for whom the document was as clear as a news article.
The operative section was in the fourth paragraph. Kaplan had underlined it in pencil, the specific thin underline of a researcher who marked rather than annotated. Colt, E., appointed to the service of the settlement as sworn Protector against Deviltry, in compensation for which the settlement commits an annual sum and the deed to property at — address, Gotham colonial coordinate system — in perpetuity of service and maintenance thereof.
Ezra Colt. 1726.
An employment record. An official government document recording the existence and compensation of a man who did something the settlement called protection against deviltry. Not folklore. Not a broadside pamphlet from a political printer with an agenda. A land deed, which was the most boring and therefore most reliable category of colonial document, because nobody put supernatural witch-hunters in land deeds unless those witch-hunters were a real administrative category that the settlement needed to document for property purposes.
He kept his face neutral. He'd had twelve hours of practice since the catacomb visit to prepare for exactly this moment — the moment when the historical record confirmed what the chapel had told him underground — and he was grateful for those twelve hours because without them the expression on his face would have been very hard to explain.
[HISTORICAL CONFIRMATION — PALE RIDER AUTHENTICITY MODIFIER: +10% BELIEF QUALITY FROM ALL FUTURE WITNESSES. Passive. Permanent. Source: Academic-grade primary document confirmation of legend's historical basis.]
Ten percent. Permanently. Every witness who believed in the Pale Rider from this point forward would generate ten percent more BP per tier per minute than the baseline rate, because the myth had a confirmed historical anchor. Academic legitimacy improved the quality of belief the same way a primary source improved the quality of an argument.
"What do you think," Kaplan said.
"I think the thesis argument needs to be restructured around this," he said. "The 1743 pamphlet I've been using as the anchor source is a secondary-echo document if this is what it was echoing. This changes the evidentiary foundation."
She sat down. The stillness came and went. "I think this is bigger than a thesis chapt er. I think this is the thesis."
"What do you mean."
"Gotham's Sanctioned Supernatural: Colonial-Era Protector Contracts." She said it the way people said things they'd been drafting in their head. "Not just the Pale Rider — if there's one contract on file, there are likely more. The settlement was documenting these as administrative categories. Which means the colonial-era supernatural protections of Gotham weren't folk legend — they were a civic institution." She looked at him. "You understand what that means for the field."
He understood what it meant for the field. He also understood, with the specific clarity of someone who was running the belief mechanics in the background, what it meant for him: an academic paper arguing from primary sources that Gotham's supernatural protector traditions were historically real, that the Pale Rider was a documented official role, that the city had sanctioned mythological defenders as a category of civic employee — that paper, if published, would reach an audience of thousands. Historians, Gotham residents who cared about local history, the paranormal enthusiasts whose forum was already discussing the sightings, the journalists who covered Gotham's strange cultural specificities.
Every person who read a peer-reviewed paper arguing that the Pale Rider was historically real and saw the Pale Rider operating in contemporary Gotham would generate belief of a quality that street-level performance couldn't match. Academic belief had a different texture than fear-based belief, a different longevity — it didn't spike and decay the way crisis belief did. It settled. It was the difference between a fire and a furnace.
"I think you're right," he said.
Something crossed Kaplan's face — not surprise exactly, but the specific pleasure of a mentor whose student had understood something important correctly. She leaned back in her chair and looked at the folder between them. "The archive access on sub-level two requires a faculty escort. I can get you in — you'll need to work systematically through the 1710–1740 material, cross-reference it with the land deed sequences. Probably three weeks of research time if you're focused about it."
"I can be focused about it."
"I know you can." She picked up her pen. Made a note. "I want a revised outline in my inbox by Monday. Not the old one — restructure it from this document forward. The 1743 pamphlet becomes corroborating evidence, not primary anchor. Lead with the land deed, build to the institutional argument."
He was already drafting in his head. Not the academic structure — that was trivial — but the larger architecture: the argument that would make Gotham's readers accept a historical supernatural protector tradition as legitimate fact, would prime them to believe in a contemporary version of it, would feed directly into the belief pool he'd been building street corner by street corner for five weeks.
Kaplan had just handed him a belief infrastructure project with academic credibility and an institutional platform, and she thought she was handing him a thesis.
He walked to the library with the archive credentials and a revised outline taking shape in his head, and the coal-warmth of the Brand against his palm, and the name Ezra Colt sitting in his chest where it had been since the catacombs.
The thesis draft was open on his laptop. He typed the new header: Gotham's Sanctioned Supernatural. Felt the system register the action in the distant low-key way it registered persona-relevant activities.
[Thesis Research — Pale Rider Persona. High authenticity depth. +75 EXP.]
He kept typing.
His phone buzzed.
Unknown number. He looked at the notification without opening it — a text preview showing enough of the first line.
We know what you've been doing at night. We'd like to talk. — Friends of Gotham.
His hands stopped over the keyboard.
He put the phone face-down on the desk and looked at the screen of his laptop for a moment, at the thesis header, at the cursor blinking.
Then he turned the phone back over and read the full message.
It was short. Seven words of contact information, a time and a location — Sunday, 9 PM, the Moldavia Theater — and the sign-off that meant something specific: Friends of Gotham.
The Moldavia Theater had been on his original performance location list, pinned in green on the map he'd deleted Monday. He'd never gone there. No one should know it had been on his list.
Someone who knew where I was planning to go before I went there.
He looked at the message again. The number had a 212 area code, which was Gotham's original exchange, which told him nothing about the sender and everything about the sender's preference for appearing legitimate. Friends of Gotham was the kind of name that organizations used when they wanted to sound civic and meant something else.
His meta-knowledge had exactly two Gotham-based organizations that operated in this register — civic on the surface, something else underneath, interested in the city's protector mythology — and one of them was the Court of Owls, who had claw marks in his origin site's basement and did not send polite texts. Which left the other one.
He had a thesis to write. He had a library credential to use and three weeks of archive material to get through and an academic paper that was going to do belief-work at scale he'd been calculating all the way from Kaplan's office.
He put the phone in his pocket and kept typing.
Sunday was four days away.
To supporting Me in Pateron .
with exclusive access to more chapters (based on tiers more chapters for each tiers) on my Patreon, you get more chapters if you ask for more (in few days), plus new fanfic every week! Your support starting at just $6/month helps me keep crafting the stories you love across epic universes.
By joining, you're not just getting more chapters—you're helping me bring new worlds, twists, and adventures to life. Every pledge makes a huge difference!
👉 Join now at patreon.com/TheFinex5 and start reading today!