Chapter 37: The Great Game — Part 1 (The Design)
[Warehouse, Bermondsey — October 3, 2010, 9:00 PM]
Five cases. Five hostages. Five puzzles calibrated to test a mind that James had spent two months studying and two years preparing to meet.
The warehouse was Moran's—one of three clean facilities rotated on a quarterly cycle, swept for surveillance, accessed through a chain of cut-outs that even Priya couldn't fully trace. James stood at a folding table under strip lighting, index cards arranged in a grid. Each card represented a case. Each case represented a question.
Moran sat across from him, cleaning a disassembled Sig Sauer with the mechanical precision of ritual. The oil smell mixed with the warehouse's permanent odour of damp concrete and cold metal.
"Five hostages," Moran said. Flat. The tone of a man stating operational parameters, not ethical objections. "Civilians. Strapped with explosives. Forced to relay your messages."
"Correct."
"And if Sherlock Holmes doesn't solve the puzzle in time?"
"The explosives are real."
Moran's hands paused on the gun barrel. One beat. Two. Then resumed. "You've killed seven people through my team. Each one vetted. Each one approved. Each one targeted for a reason. Civilians in bomb vests is different."
"The hostages won't die if Sherlock performs as expected. The bombs are motivation, not execution."
"And if he doesn't perform?"
James picked up the first index card. Turned it in his fingers. The card stock was cheap—WHSmith, the same brand as the notebook Kevin had brought him that second morning, the morning when the world was new and a bacon sandwich was the kindest thing anyone had done for him. Thirty-one months ago. A different man holding different cards.
"Then we learn something too," James said.
The design had taken three weeks. Each case was a message in a language Sherlock would understand—the language of criminal methodology, spoken through the grammar of deduction. James had built them the way he'd built consulting engagements in his previous life: with clear objectives, measurable outcomes, and difficulty curves calibrated to the audience.
Case One: A dead man's shoes. A body found in the Thames wearing trainers that don't belong to him. The deduction required: identifying the victim through footwear analysis, connecting to a cold case from 1989. Testing: basic observational methodology. Difficulty: moderate. Time limit: twelve hours.
Case Two: A missing car and a blood trail. A businessman vanishes; his car found with evidence of violence. The truth: insurance fraud, self-inflicted wounds, the businessman hiding in his lover's flat. Testing: lateral thinking, ability to see past obvious conclusions. Difficulty: moderate-high. Time limit: eight hours.
Case Three: A murdered television presenter. Found dead with an apparent suicide note. The deduction: identifying the real killer through handwriting analysis and timeline reconstruction. Testing: forensic attention to detail. Difficulty: high. Time limit: ten hours.
Case Four: An old woman. Twelve pips. This one was different—the hostage would describe Moriarty's voice. A test within a test: could Sherlock accept information from a dying source while managing emotional interference? Testing: composure under personal threat. Difficulty: psychological. Time limit: twelve hours.
Case Five: The Vermeer. A painting declared genuine by every expert—but fake. The evidence: a supernova recorded in 1858, visible in the painting's sky, impossible if the painting was truly seventeenth-century. Testing: interdisciplinary knowledge, the ability to connect art history with astrophysics. Difficulty: exceptional. Time limit: twelve hours.
"The escalation is deliberate," James said. "Each case more complex than the last. Each hostage more sympathetic. By the fifth, Sherlock will be operating at maximum cognitive output under maximum emotional pressure. That's when I'll see what he's really made of."
"And after the fifth?"
"After the fifth, we meet."
Moran reassembled the Sig in four clean movements. Set it on the table. "Where?"
"Somewhere theatrical. Somewhere that matches the performance."
"You have somewhere in mind."
"A pool. The kind of place where sound carries and exits are visible and the confrontation has nowhere to hide." James set down the index cards. Aligned them in their grid. Five cases, five tests, five questions that would determine whether Sherlock Holmes was the opponent this game deserved. "I want him to see me. Properly. Not through a dying cabbie's last word or a surveillance report. Face to face."
"That's a risk."
"That's the point."
---
James drove home alone. No Kevin—transport was compartmentalised, and tonight's meeting existed outside the normal operational channels. The car was rented, the route circuitous, the habit of security so deeply embedded that it had become indistinguishable from personality.
The flat was dark. He didn't turn on the lights. Sat at the kitchen table in the glow of the street lamp filtering through the window, the green scarf still around his neck—Molly's scarf, the hand-knitted one with the uneven stitches that he wore more days than not, the warmth of it a reminder that somewhere in this city was a woman who thought he fixed computers and loved him anyway.
He was wearing it while planning games of death. The contradiction was clear. He didn't take it off.
The Jim phone buzzed. Molly: Dinner Friday? I'm thinking that Thai place you liked. The one with the good pad thai and the aggressive cat. 🐈🍜
James typed: Perfect. I'll book. 7:30?
You're on. Love you, Jim.
Love you too.
He set the phone down. Picked up the Moriarty phone. Five cases. Five hostages. Somewhere between the pad thai and the pool, two lives would collide—not with the gentle friction of parallel orbits, but with the catastrophic force of bodies that had been pretending they occupied separate universes.
The scarf was warm. The flat was cold. The game was ready.
Note:
Read the raw, unfiltered story as it unfolds. Your support makes this possible!
👉 Find it all at patreon.com/Whatif0
Timeline Viewer ($6): Get 10 chapters of early access + 5 new chapters weekly.
Timeline Explorer ($9): Jump 15-20 chapters ahead of everyone.
Timeline Keeper ($15): Get Instant Access to chapters the moment I finish writing them. No more waiting.