Cherreads

Chapter 10 - Chapter 10: When The Past Shows up

AURORA:

The house was quiet in a way Aurora had started to recognize.

Not empty.

Just calm.

There was a difference now.

Before, the silence in the house had felt heavy, like something was missing. Now, it felt softer. Warmer in small, quiet ways that didn't demand attention but were still there if you noticed them.

Aurora stood near the window in the living room, watching Isabella carefully trace the letters in her book with her finger.

The little girl's lips moved slightly as she read, her voice barely above a whisper.

"Ho… me…"

Aurora smiled gently.

"Home," she said softly.

Isabella looked up immediately, her eyes lighting just a little.

"Home," she repeated.

Aurora nodded.

"That's right."

There was something about these moments that felt important in ways Aurora couldn't fully explain. They weren't dramatic. They weren't big. But they mattered.

Isabella was trying.

Opening up slowly.

And Aurora found herself caring more than she should.

"Can we do another one?" Isabella asked.

Aurora nodded and sat beside her on the floor.

"Of course."

She picked another word from the book, pointing at it gently.

"What about this one?"

Isabella leaned closer, her shoulder brushing lightly against Aurora's arm.

"Fa… mi…"

"Family," Aurora finished softly.

Isabella repeated it slowly.

"Family."

The word hung in the air for a second longer than it should have.

Aurora felt it.

So did Isabella.

The child's fingers tightened slightly around the page, but she didn't say anything.

Aurora didn't push.

She just turned the page quietly.

The doorbell rang.

The sound cut through the calm of the house sharply.

Aurora frowned slightly.

Luca wasn't home yet.

He usually didn't return until later.

She stood up slowly.

"Stay here," she said gently to Isabella. "I'll be back."

Isabella nodded, but her expression had changed slightly — cautious, uncertain.

Aurora noticed, but didn't question it.

She walked toward the door, her steps calm but alert.

Something about the timing felt… off.

When she opened the door, the first thing she noticed was the smell.

Strong.

Unpleasant.

Alcohol.

Then she saw her.

The woman standing at the door looked like she hadn't slept properly in days. Her hair was messy, her makeup slightly smudged, her clothes expensive but worn in a careless way that didn't match the house she was standing in front of.

Her eyes moved slowly over Aurora, unfocused for a second before settling.

"You're new," she said.

Her voice was rough.

Aurora didn't step back.

"Yes," she replied calmly. "Can I help you?"

The woman let out a small, humorless laugh.

"Help me?" she repeated. "That's funny."

Aurora stayed quiet.

"I'm not here for you," the woman continued, her tone shifting slightly. "I'm here for my daughter."

Aurora's chest tightened.

She didn't react immediately.

But she understood.

"Isabella?" the woman called suddenly, her voice louder now.

Aurora stepped forward slightly.

"You shouldn't raise your voice," she said gently but firmly.

The woman's eyes snapped back to her.

"Don't tell me what I should do in my own house."

The words were sharp.

But unstable.

Aurora didn't respond to that.

Instead, she turned slightly—

Too late.

"Stop."

The small voice came from behind her.

Aurora turned immediately.

Isabella stood a few steps away, her body stiff, her eyes fixed on the woman at the door.

All the softness from earlier had disappeared.

The woman smiled.

But it wasn't warm.

"Isabella," she said, almost lazily. "Come here."

Isabella didn't move.

Aurora felt it instantly — the tension, the fear, the resistance.

The child's hand moved slowly, reaching for Aurora's sleeve.

Holding it.

Tight.

"I said come here," the woman repeated.

Aurora placed her hand gently over Isabella's, not pulling her forward, not pushing her back.

Just there.

Steady.

"She doesn't want to," Aurora said softly.

The woman's expression darkened slightly.

"And who are you to decide that?"

Aurora met her gaze calmly.

"I'm not deciding," she said. "She is."

Silence.

Heavy.

Unstable.

The woman took a step forward.

Aurora didn't move.

Neither did Isabella.

"You think you can replace me?" the woman asked quietly, her voice suddenly sharper.

Aurora shook her head once.

"No."

The answer was simple.

Honest.

And for some reason, that made it worse.

"Then step aside."

Aurora didn't.

Behind her, Isabella's grip tightened.

"No," the child whispered.

The word was small.

But clear.

Something in the woman's expression cracked.

Not completely.

Just enough to show something underneath the instability.

Hurt.

Or anger.

Or both.

"You don't get to say no to me," she snapped suddenly.

Isabella flinched.

Aurora's hand tightened slightly around hers.

"You need to leave," Aurora said gently.

The woman laughed again.

But this time, it wasn't soft.

"You're telling me to leave my own house?"

Aurora didn't raise her voice.

"Not like this," she said quietly.

Another silence.

Then—

Footsteps behind the woman.

A car door.

Voices outside.

Aurora's attention shifted for a second.

The woman noticed.

And that was when she smiled again.

Slow.

Unsettling.

"Good," she said quietly. "He's here."

Aurora's heart dropped slightly.

Because she already knew.

Luca had just arrived.

The sound of the car door closing echoed through the quiet street.

Aurora felt it before she saw him.

The shift in the air.

The tension tightening.

The woman at the door straightened slightly, brushing a hand through her already messy hair like she was trying to pull herself together in a few seconds.

Too late.

Luca stepped through the gate.

His movements were calm.

Controlled.

But the moment his eyes landed on the scene in front of him, something in his expression changed.

Not dramatically.

Just enough.

Aurora stood at the doorway, Isabella slightly behind her, holding onto her sleeve.

And in front of them—

Her.

Luca stopped.

Completely.

For a second, no one spoke.

Then the woman smiled.

"Luca."

His name sounded wrong in her voice.

Too familiar.

Too careless.

Aurora watched him closely.

She expected anger.

Shock.

Something.

But what she saw instead was something colder.

Recognition.

Followed by a quiet, controlled tension that settled into his posture like he had been expecting this, just not today.

"You shouldn't be here," Luca said.

His voice was calm.

Too calm.

The woman tilted her head slightly.

"That's how you greet your wife?"

Aurora felt Isabella stiffen behind her.

The child's grip tightened.

LUCA:

"I asked you not to come here like this," Luca continued.

"I didn't feel like listening," she replied easily.

Silence stretched again.

Heavy.

Uncomfortable.

Luca's gaze shifted slightly.

To Isabella.

Just for a second.

That was enough.

"Go inside," he said quietly.

Aurora felt Isabella hesitate.

She didn't move immediately.

Aurora leaned slightly toward her.

"It's okay," she whispered gently.

Isabella looked up at her, then slowly nodded.

But she didn't let go immediately.

Aurora gently loosened the child's grip.

"Go," she said softly.

Isabella stepped back slowly.

But her eyes never left the woman.

There was no warmth in them.

No excitement.

Only discomfort.

Distance.

The woman noticed.

And something sharp flickered across her face.

"What?" she said suddenly. "You're not going to hug your mother?"

Isabella froze.

Aurora's chest tightened.

"Stop," Luca said.

One word.

Firm.

The woman turned to him.

"What?" she snapped. "She's my daughter."

"And you're not in a state to be near her," Luca replied calmly.

The words hit.

Hard.

For a second, the woman just stared at him.

Then she laughed.

But it sounded wrong.

Too loud.

Too empty.

"You're unbelievable," she said. "You act like I'm the problem."

Luca didn't respond.

Aurora stayed where she was.

She didn't step forward.

Didn't step back.

But she didn't leave either.

Because Isabella was still behind her.

"You brought a nanny into my house," the woman continued, her eyes flicking toward Aurora. "And now you're acting like I don't belong here?"

Aurora didn't react.

But she could feel Luca's attention shift briefly toward her.

Then back.

"This isn't about her," Luca said.

"It clearly is," the woman shot back. "She's standing where I should be."

Aurora finally spoke.

Her voice was soft.

Calm.

"I'm not replacing anyone."

The woman's eyes snapped to her.

"And yet you're here."

Aurora didn't argue.

Didn't defend herself.

"I'm here for Isabella," she said simply.

That made the silence heavier.

The woman stepped closer.

Unsteady.

But determined.

"Then let me see my daughter," she said.

Aurora didn't move.

Behind her, Isabella shifted.

A small step back.

Luca saw it.

That was enough.

"No."

The word came out sharper this time.

The woman stopped.

"What do you mean no?"

"You're not seeing her like this," Luca said.

Something in his voice had changed.

Less controlled.

More… final.

The woman's expression twisted.

"You don't get to decide that."

"I already did."

Silence.

Aurora could feel the tension rising again.

Faster this time.

More dangerous.

The woman let out a breath, running her hand through her hair again.

"Fine," she said suddenly.

Too quickly.

Luca didn't relax.

"I'll come back," she continued, her voice quieter now. "When you're ready to stop acting like I'm a stranger."

Luca didn't answer.

Her eyes moved one last time—

To Aurora.

Then to Isabella.

Something unreadable passed through them.

Then she turned.

And walked away.

The gate closed behind her.

And just like that—

The silence returned.

But it wasn't the same silence as before.

Aurora turned slowly.

Isabella stood behind her, her face pale, her eyes distant.

"It's okay," Aurora said gently.

But Isabella shook her head slightly.

"No," she whispered.

Aurora's heart tightened.

From the doorway, Luca watched them.

Quiet.

Still.

But something inside him had shifted again.

And this time—

It wasn't just control he was losing.

The house was quiet again.

But not the kind of quiet Luca was used to.

This one felt different.

Heavier.

Like something had been shaken loose and hadn't settled back into place yet.

He stood near the doorway for a moment longer than necessary, his gaze fixed on the space where she had just been.

Her presence still lingered.

Faint.

Unwelcome.

He should have expected it.

He had known, from the moment things started going too smoothly, that something would interrupt it. That something from the past would find its way back into his life when he least wanted it.

It always did.

Behind him, he heard a soft sound.

A small shift.

He turned.

Isabella.

She was standing where Aurora had left her, her small frame still, her expression distant in a way Luca recognized immediately.

Too familiar.

Too quiet.

That look again.

Luca's chest tightened slightly.

He didn't hesitate this time.

He walked toward her slowly, stopping just a step away.

"Isabella," he said quietly.

She didn't respond immediately.

Her eyes lifted to his, but there was no relief in them.

No comfort.

Just uncertainty.

"I don't like her," she said.

The words were soft.

But clear.

Luca exhaled slowly.

"I know."

Isabella's fingers tightened slightly against her dress.

"She smells strange," she added.

Luca's jaw tightened.

He forced himself to stay calm.

"She's not well," he said.

It was the simplest explanation.

The safest one.

Isabella didn't ask more.

She never did.

Instead, she stepped back slightly.

Not from him.

From everything.

And then—

She turned.

Not toward him.

Toward Aurora.

Luca followed her movement.

Aurora was still there.

Standing quietly.

Not too close.

Not too far.

Just… present.

Isabella walked straight to her and stopped.

Then, without a word, she reached for her.

Aurora didn't hesitate.

She knelt down immediately, wrapping her arms around the child gently, her movements careful, steady.

Not overwhelming.

Not uncertain.

Just enough.

Isabella leaned into her.

And Luca felt it again.

That unfamiliar shift in his chest.

Something tightening.

Something he didn't want to name.

Because it wasn't just relief.

It wasn't just gratitude.

It was something else.

Something closer to… dependence.

Luca looked away first.

He moved back slightly, giving them space, even though he wasn't sure why he felt the need to.

Aurora wasn't doing anything wrong.

She was doing exactly what she was there to do.

But it didn't feel like just a job anymore.

He could see it.

In the way Isabella held onto her.

In the way Aurora responded without hesitation.

In the way the house felt… different when she was there.

And that was the problem.

Luca ran a hand slowly through his hair, exhaling under his breath.

Control.

He needed to regain it.

"She's not staying," he said.

The words were meant to reassure.

To bring things back into order.

Aurora looked up at him.

Not surprised.

Not questioning.

Just calm.

"I know," she said softly.

That was all.

No questions.

No pressure.

And somehow, that made it harder.

Most people would have asked.

Would have wanted explanations.

Would have pushed.

Aurora didn't.

She simply accepted what he said.

And returned her attention to Isabella.

Like that was what mattered.

Luca watched them for a moment longer.

Then turned away.

He walked into his office and closed the door behind him.

The quiet inside the room was immediate.

Familiar.

Controlled.

But it didn't settle him the way it used to.

He leaned against the desk, his hands resting on the surface as he stared down at nothing.

Her face.

Her voice.

Her presence.

It all came back again.

The way she had stood at the door.

Unmoved.

Calm.

Protective.

She hadn't raised her voice.

Hadn't argued.

Hadn't tried to prove anything.

But she hadn't stepped aside either.

And that—

That stayed with him.

A knock on the door broke his thoughts.

"Come in."

Matteo stepped inside without hesitation.

His eyes moved quickly over Luca, taking in everything in a single glance.

"She came, didn't she?"

Luca didn't ask how he knew.

"Yes."

Matteo exhaled quietly.

"I figured she would eventually."

Silence.

"She saw Isabella?" Matteo asked.

Luca nodded once.

"And?"

Luca's expression hardened slightly.

"It didn't go well."

Matteo didn't look surprised.

"It never does with her," he said quietly.

Luca looked away.

"She's not coming back here like that," he said.

Matteo studied him.

"You can't control that completely," he replied. "You know that."

Luca's jaw tightened.

"I'll handle it."

Matteo didn't argue.

But his next words were quieter.

More careful.

"And Aurora?"

Luca stilled.

"What about her?"

Matteo didn't rush.

"She was there," he said. "When it happened."

Luca didn't respond immediately.

"Yes."

"And?"

Luca exhaled slowly.

"She handled it."

That was an understatement.

Matteo noticed.

"That's not all," he said.

Luca looked at him.

Matteo held his gaze.

"You trust her."

The words were simple.

But they landed deeper than anything else.

Luca didn't deny it.

Because he couldn't.

And that was the problem.

Because trust led to attachment.

And attachment—

Led to loss.

Luca looked away again.

"She's part of the problem now," he said quietly.

Matteo didn't respond immediately.

"No," he said finally. "She's part of the change."

Luca didn't answer.

Because he didn't know which one was worse.

More Chapters