CHAPTER 12: THE MISSING WHO AREN'T
[Seattle Police Department, Downtown Precinct — Mid-April 2015, 10:30 AM]
[Major]
The folder was thinner than it should have been.
Major Lilywhite sat in the hard plastic chair beside Detective Babineaux's desk and stared at the three photographs spread across the surface — three faces, three names, three kids who'd stopped coming to the shelter and whose case workers had moved on to the next crisis. The folder held intake forms, last-known-address records, and the specific kind of institutional indifference that accumulated around people nobody was paid to look for.
Three missing teenagers. Not zero — which would mean the system worked. Not fifteen, which would mean the system had catastrophically failed. Three. A number that sat in the bureaucratic dead zone between anomaly and pattern, too large to ignore and too small to demand resources.
"Eddie Torres, seventeen." Major tapped the first photo. A school picture — shy smile, collar crooked, the expression of a kid who'd been told to sit still and hadn't quite managed it. "Last seen at the Capitol Hill shelter six weeks ago. His case worker assumed he'd aged out."
"He didn't age out," Clive said. He pulled the second chair around and sat facing Major, notebook open. The detective's posture was professional but not dismissive — he was listening, which was more than the intake officer downstairs had done. "He's seventeen. Too young."
"Right. He just... stopped showing up. Nobody filed anything for two weeks." Major moved to the second photo. "Kenisha Brown, sixteen. Same shelter, same pattern. Last seen four weeks ago."
"And the third?"
"A kid who goes by 'Dex.' Nobody knows his real name. The shelter doesn't require legal identification — that's the whole point, some of these kids are running from the system. He was there for about a month, then gone."
Clive wrote. The pen moved in short, efficient strokes. "And you've contacted the other shelters?"
"All of them. Pike Place, the one on Pine, the new one in Rainier Beach." Major's hands were flat on his knees. Large hands, the kind that belonged to a former Division I athlete who now used them to serve cafeteria lunches and break up arguments over PlayStation controllers. "Some of these kids bounce between locations. But Eddie had a routine — he was there every night, same bunk, same time. Then nothing."
"Any connection between the three? Friends, mutual contacts, shared histories?"
"Eddie and Kenisha knew each other. Dex was a loner." Major paused. His jaw tightened, released. "Detective, I know three missing kids in Seattle doesn't exactly trigger an AMBER alert. But I work at that shelter. I see these kids every day. And when three of them vanish inside of six weeks..."
"You want someone to care."
"I want someone to look."
Clive closed his notebook. Not a dismissal — a recalibration. The detective's face shifted from professional reception to something harder to read: the expression of a man who'd heard a hundred versions of this story and still hadn't developed immunity to it.
"I'll open a preliminary inquiry. No promises about resources — we're stretched thin. But I'll pull what records exist on all three and see if anything connects."
"That's all I'm asking."
Major stood. The handshake was firm. He left the bullpen through the main corridor, past the duty sergeant's desk, past the vending machine that charged two dollars for a Coke and never gave correct change. Through the glass partition, he could see the rest of the detectives' desks — some occupied, most buried under paperwork, the organized chaos of a department that had too many cases and not enough hours.
The folder stayed on Clive's desk. Three photos. Three names. A thinner file than another version of this moment would have produced — because in another version, another timeline, the folder would have held seven names, then twelve, then more. In that version, Major Lilywhite would have come to this desk not with a concern but with a crusade, his voice cracking with the specific desperation of a man who'd watched his kids disappear one by one into a machine he couldn't see.
This version was quieter. Less urgent. The machine had stopped grinding three weeks ago — a different man in a different butcher shop had reached for the off switch, and the silence it left was the sound of teenagers who were still alive because a monster had been replaced by someone marginally less monstrous.
Three missing instead of twelve. Three names on a desk instead of a crisis on a whiteboard.
The butterfly had flapped its wings, and somewhere a storm had been downgraded to a breeze.
[King County Medical Examiner's Office — 11:45 AM]
[Liv]
The bullpen was visible from the corridor that connected the ME's office to the precinct's administrative wing — a walkway Liv used twice a week to deliver autopsy reports and once a week to steal decent coffee from the break room because the morgue's machine produced something that tasted like institutional regret.
She was returning from a coffee run when she saw Major through the glass.
He stood at Clive's desk. Tall, earnest, his posture carrying the specific tension of someone making a case they expected to lose. Liv stopped. The coffee cup — Clive's, not hers, a peace offering she brought on Thursdays because Clive never remembered his own and the vending Coke wasn't going to cut it — warmed her hand through the paper sleeve.
She couldn't hear the conversation. But she could read the scene: Major's hands gesturing at photographs on the desk. Clive's notebook open. The tilt of Major's shoulders when he leaned forward, making a point. The way Clive's pen paused — the detective processing, weighing, deciding whether this was worth the hours it would cost.
Then Major said something. Two words that Liv caught through the glass — lip-reading wasn't her strongest skill, but she'd spent enough time in the morgue studying silent mouths to recognize common phrases.
Missing kids.
The vision hit without warning. Not the full sensory assault from the Torres brain — that had been consumed and processed weeks ago, the personality residue faded. This was an echo. A ghost of the original vision, triggered by context: missing kids, a police desk, the word that connected it all.
Eddie Torres. Blaine DeBeers' face. The knife. The parking lot. Rain.
The coffee cup trembled in her hand. She gripped it tighter. The tremor stopped. She was a medical examiner's assistant and a zombie and a woman who'd learned to compress inconvenient emotions into spaces small enough to function around.
She kept walking. Past the glass partition, past Clive's desk, past Major without making eye contact. In the break room, she set Clive's coffee on the counter beside the microwave and stood with her back to the door for thirty seconds, breathing.
Major Lilywhite. Her ex-fiancé. The man she'd broken off the engagement with because she'd been turned into a zombie at a boat party and couldn't explain why she suddenly craved brains and avoided sunlight without admitting that she'd become the kind of monster that horror movies used to make her cover her eyes.
He was at Clive's desk. Reporting missing kids. Kids who matched the profile of the boy whose murder she'd witnessed through his own dead eyes.
Two data points.
The phrase surfaced from the analytical part of her brain — the part that Ravi called her "inner detective" and that she called "the thing that makes my life harder." Eddie Torres: murdered by Blaine DeBeers, confirmed through brain vision, body recovered from a shallow grave. Missing kids from a Capitol Hill shelter: reported by Major, connected to the same neighborhood where Blaine's butcher shop operated.
Two points made a line. And the line pointed at Meat Cute.
She left the break room. Walked back to the ME's office. Past the corridor, past the glass, past the bullpen where Major was shaking Clive's hand and walking toward the elevator with the particular stride of a man who'd done what he could and was trying to believe it was enough.
She didn't approach him. The reasons stacked: she couldn't explain her knowledge without exposing her zombie status. She couldn't connect Eddie Torres to the missing kids without revealing the vision. And she couldn't talk to Major — about this, about anything — without the conversation spiraling toward the broken engagement and the secrets she was carrying and the specific, exhausting lie that her entire post-boat-party life had become.
The ME's office was quiet. Ravi was at lunch — the man's circadian eating schedule was immovable, twelve-thirty to one-fifteen, every day, no exceptions, because Ravi believed that skipping meals was the first step toward "civilizational decline" and he'd once delivered a seventeen-minute lecture on the subject to a vending machine.
Liv sat at her desk. Opened her laptop. Pulled up the Eddie Torres file — cause of death, autopsy photos, the preliminary report she'd typed with hands that had shaken on every keystroke.
Then she opened the missing persons query system. Three names. Eddie Torres matched one — his case was technically closed, body recovered, homicide pending investigation. The other two — Kenisha Brown and the kid called Dex — were open. Last known location: Capitol Hill shelter. Last known movements: undefined.
She printed the three records. Stood up. Walked to the corkboard above her desk — the one that held Blaine's driver's license photo, a Post-it that still said call Mom (she hadn't), and the Chinese delivery flyer she should've thrown away weeks ago.
She pinned the missing-kids bulletin next to Blaine's photo. Took a red dry-erase marker — she'd switched from pen to marker because pins and string felt too much like a police procedural and she wasn't ready to admit this was becoming one.
Drew a line. Blaine's photo to Eddie Torres. Eddie Torres to the missing kids flyer.
Two data points. One line. One direction.
She stared at the corkboard. The fluorescent light buzzed overhead. Somewhere in the building, a body was being delivered to the intake bay — the thump of a gurney wheel catching on the threshold, the squeak of rubber on linoleum. Standard sounds. Background noise. The percussion section of her daily life.
Blaine DeBeers ran a butcher shop in a neighborhood where teenagers disappeared. She'd seen his face through a dead boy's eyes. And now her ex-fiancé was reporting more missing kids to her partner detective, and the geometry of it all — Blaine, the shelter, the knife, the shallow grave — was tightening into a shape she could almost name.
She picked up her phone. Scrolled to Ravi's contact. Typed: We need to talk about Blaine. Tonight. Bring wine.
Sent.
[Emerald City Youth Shelter, Capitol Hill — 4:00 PM]
[Major]
The gymnasium smelled like floor wax and teenagers — a combination that no amount of industrial ventilation could fully address. Major had spent three years breathing it, and somewhere around month eight it had stopped registering as a smell and started registering as home.
Jerome was shooting free throws at the far basket. Sixteen, lanky, left-handed, with a release point that was two inches too low and a follow-through that curled instead of extending. Major had been trying to correct it for six months. Jerome had been politely ignoring the advice for six months. The dynamic worked.
"Detective said he'd look into it." Major caught the rebound and bounced it back. "No promises."
"No promises." Jerome lined up another shot. Brick. The ball ricocheted off the rim and Major snagged it one-handed. "That means nothing's gonna happen."
"It means someone's paying attention."
"Paying attention and doing something are different things." Jerome caught the pass. Set his feet. Shot. This time it kissed the glass and dropped clean. "You hear about the Seahawks draft? They're looking at this cornerback from Bama—"
The pivot was deliberate. Major recognized it — the same conversational redirect he'd seen from a hundred kids who'd learned that talking about what scared them was less useful than talking about anything else. Eddie Torres had slept four bunks from Jerome. They'd argued about music — Eddie liked trap, Jerome liked old-school hip-hop, and the debate had been loud enough to draw a noise complaint from the night supervisor.
Now Eddie was in a morgue drawer and Jerome was shooting free throws and neither of them would acknowledge the gap between what was and what should have been.
"I heard about the cornerback," Major said. "His forty time is insane."
"Four-three-two. Dude runs like he's got somewhere to be."
"Don't we all."
They shot hoops for another twenty minutes. The gymnasium echoed with the sound of the ball hitting hardwood — a rhythm that asked nothing and expected nothing and filled the space where missing names used to be.
Major drove home in silence. The radio stayed off. The folder on his passenger seat — the copy he'd kept, three photos, three names — slid against the leather every time he took a turn. A thinner folder than it should have been. And the silence where twelve names should have lived was deafening if you knew how to listen.
He didn't know. Not yet. The man in the butcher shop had turned off the machine, and the sound of its absence was a kind of mercy that nobody would recognize until much later.
[King County Medical Examiner's Office — 6:15 PM]
[Liv]
Ravi arrived with a bottle of Merlot and two travel mugs, because Ravi believed that if you were going to drink wine in a morgue, you should at least do it with dignity, and wine glasses didn't survive the autoclave.
Liv pointed at the corkboard.
Ravi looked at it. Looked at her. Looked at the corkboard again.
"Well," he said. "That's rather damning, isn't it."
"It's a line. Two points and a line."
"Which points at a man who owns a butcher shop and whose face you saw holding a knife over a teenager." Ravi poured wine into both travel mugs. "And now your ex-boyfriend is reporting more missing teenagers from the same area."
"Major isn't part of this. He just—"
"He walked into the same investigation from a completely different door. Which is rather the definition of convergence." Ravi handed her a mug. "What are you going to do?"
Liv took the wine. Drank. Set it down.
"I'm going to find the third point."
Note:
Read the raw, unfiltered story as it unfolds. Your support makes this possible!
👉 Find it all at patreon.com/Whatif0
Timeline Viewer ($6): Get 10 chapters of early access + 5 new chapters weekly.
Timeline Explorer ($9): Jump 15-20 chapters ahead of everyone.
Timeline Keeper ($15): Get Instant Access to chapters the moment I finish writing them. No more waiting.