Chapter 64: The Beginning of the Tragedy
The gate of Creel House gave a single quiet creak as Joyce eased it open, the kind of sound old iron made when it hadn't been moved in a while. The noise lasted half a second and then the silence took it back, deeper than before.
The smell hit them at the threshold — furniture polish gone stale, dust, and underneath both of those something else, something with an electric quality, like the air after lightning had moved through it.
The foyer was dark in a way that felt intentional. Not the normal dark of a house at night with the lights off, but the kind of dark that seemed to resist the idea of light on principle. Even the ambient glow from the street outside stopped at the door.
Three flashlight beams came on simultaneously, crossing and sweeping through the space — finding peeling wallpaper in a floral pattern that had probably been cheerful in 1930, heavy curtains that hadn't been opened in some time, an umbrella stand in the corner with one umbrella in it. Where the beams hit directly, everything was sharp and clear, the shadows thrown off to the sides long and strange, pressed against the walls in shapes that were almost recognizable.
"Power's out?" Joyce kept her voice low but the foyer threw it back at her anyway. She moved to the front, her beam working the hallway, her free hand closing into a fist at her side without her deciding to do it. Her heart was doing what it did in situations like this — faster, insistent — but it had never once been enough to stop her from going forward, and tonight was no different.
Hopper came in behind her, stepping over something on the floor.
"Hey," he said, holding his left hand up into his own flashlight beam, "I'm bleeding. Cut it on the window glass coming in."
In the light, the wound across the base of his thumb was visible — two inches, clean edges, blood moving in slow beads down his palm and dropping into the dust on the floor, leaving small dark circles.
Neither Joyce nor Bob responded. Joyce's beam was sweeping the hallway ahead. Bob was scanning the walls and ceiling with the focused expression of someone running calculations.
"The fuse box," Bob said, pointing his light at a ceramic panel set into the corner of the ceiling near the hallway entrance. The cover hung open. The interior was blackened, the components inside showing the specific char pattern of something that had failed under load, not worn out gradually. "Surge blew it. Same thing that took out the D.A.D. — a sudden spike of current beyond what the system could handle. Whatever generated that field, it was pulling enough power to take out the house wiring."
"Okay, but also I'm bleeding," Hopper said, wiping his hand on his jeans and making it worse.
"Shh." Joyce had stopped moving. Her head was tilted.
The static was still there. It had been there since they crossed the threshold, low and pervasive, not coming from any single location but from everywhere at once, like the house itself was the source. But underneath it, threading through it at irregular intervals—
"You hear that?" Joyce said.
Bob heard it. His face, half-lit by his own flashlight, went careful. "Could be residual electromagnetic interference from the surge. You sometimes get audio artifacts from—"
"It's not that," Joyce said.
She didn't raise her voice. She didn't need to. There was a quality of certainty in it that both of them recognized as the specific certainty Joyce had when she'd decided something was true.
The sound under the static was doing something. It had a rhythm that kept almost resolving into something recognizable and then breaking apart again. The fragments in it — whatever they were — carried urgency.
"What if we're wrong about the animals?" Bob's voice had gone to a register that meant his imagination had taken him somewhere he didn't want to be. "What if they weren't — what if they were just practice? Or—"
"I'm bleeding," Hopper said, at a volume slightly above the previous attempts. He waved his hand through Joyce's flashlight beam, the blood catching the light briefly. "Does that not register as information to either of you?"
"Hopper." Joyce turned her head just long enough to look at him. Her flashlight found his face. "Be quiet."
She turned back to the hallway.
Bob made a silencing gesture with his free hand, which under the circumstances was slightly redundant.
The three of them went still. The flashlight beams stabilized. In the silence they'd made, the house filled the space they'd vacated — the background static, the deep-structure groan of old wood, and that other sound, the one under everything, that was getting more frequent and harder to dismiss.
Then, from the direction of the dining room: a single clean click.
The sound of a small hard object making contact with a hard floor.
"What was—" Hopper started.
Joyce moved her beam toward the dining room doorway. It carved through, illuminating the long table and the high-backed chairs arranged around it in the specific way furniture looked in a room that hadn't been used for its intended purpose in some time. Still. Nothing moving.
She started to move the beam.
A figure exploded out of the darkness on the far side of the dining table.
Bob's flashlight hit the floor. He didn't throw it — his hand just opened. The flashlight bounced once and rolled, coming to rest with the beam pointing at the ceiling, throwing everything into indirect light.
The figure had stopped in the center of that indirect light.
Victor Creel. His shirt was badly wrinkled, his tie loose and crooked, his hair without any of the deliberate pomade he'd had at the parent-teacher meeting hours ago. His face was wet — sweat and something else. His eyes were wide, pupils contracting to near-nothing in the flashlight's glow, but not tracking normally, looking slightly past whoever was in front of him rather than at them.
He didn't appear to know who he was looking at. He'd been drawn toward the light the way people in certain states were drawn toward lights, and now that he'd found it, he was talking at it.
"It was an accident!" His voice was raw, used up, carrying the specific exhaustion of someone who had been having this conversation in their own head for hours and was finally having it out loud. "I never meant — we had to pull back, we had to, the intel was wrong, I didn't know there were—" He waved both arms in front of him, batting at something invisible, then turned as if to go back into the dark.
"Who is that?" Hopper picked up Bob's flashlight, brought both beams up, locking the figure in the light. The face was familiar. The name was right there.
"Victor Creel," Joyce said, beside him. "Henry's father."
She said it with the flat certainty of someone who had already moved to the next thought. Her eyes had gone bright in a way Hopper recognized from drama club rehearsals — she'd connected something.
"He's been acting like this all night," she said, faster now, working through it. "The animals all belonged to girls in the production. The incidents have a pattern. Victor's been in the house — Victor is the one who had access, who knew the area, who is clearly—" She looked at Hopper. "He's the one killing the animals. Victor's the killer."
"We caught him," Bob breathed. He'd retrieved his flashlight from the floor. The fear of two minutes ago had been replaced, almost completely, by the specific excitement of a mystery resolving. "The reward. We actually—"
The scream came from upstairs.
A girl's voice, young, saturated with the specific combination of pain and terror that couldn't be performed, that only happened when it was real.
The excitement on Bob's face stopped. The color left it. Something more fundamental took over.
"That's Patty." His voice had no air in it. "That's my sister."
He was moving before the sentence finished, not running toward the stairs so much as simply being there, all other considerations gone.
"Victor's getting away!" Hopper watched Victor, startled by the scream, lurch backward into the darkness of the far dining room and disappear. He looked between the darkness that had swallowed Victor and the staircase where Bob was already halfway up.
One second. Two.
Joyce was following Bob.
"Upstairs," she said, without looking back.
Hopper looked once more toward the dining room darkness. Then he followed.
The stairs announced every step.
Patti came back into herself all at once, like surfacing from water.
One moment she was somewhere that wasn't the attic — a void, dark and dimensionless, with Henry's image in front of her like a bad TV signal, shifting through versions of itself, different ages, different expressions of the same pain — and then she was on the attic floor with her back against the slanted wall and her body telling her several things about the last few minutes that she needed a moment to process.
The journey through Henry's memory hadn't been a dream. It hadn't been imagination. It had been his — all of it, everything she'd seen, real and sourced and entirely his.
Victor's voice, coming from all directions, worn down to something that was half-justification and half-apology: he's re-entering school, the last school was an accident, they don't understand, they don't know what we've been through—
The school hallway. Walter Henderson's voice, doing the thing it always did — sharp, entertained by the wrong things, carrying the specific cruelty of a teenager who had found a target: I heard you blinded a kid at your last school. That true?
She'd felt the weight of it from the inside. Not the weight of watching someone be said that to, but the weight of being the person it was said to, on the first day in a new school, in a new town, carrying everything Henry had arrived in Hawkins carrying.
The drama club backstage. Hopper's face, testing something, leaning against a cabinet with the specific ease of someone who didn't need to work to fill a room: Has anyone ever told you you're a little creepy?
And then Claudia, at the church, her grief enormous and pointed: The devil has come to Hawkins!
Patti had felt the confusion underneath Henry's stillness in those moments. The wanting to belong and the wall that kept going up regardless. The fear, underneath all of it, of being found out — not because he'd done anything wrong, but because he knew what he was capable of and so did everyone around him.
And then Nevada.
The playground at the edge of another school, the light going amber and low, a boy she didn't know with a face twisted past the point where anger looked like anger anymore and into something that was grief wearing anger's face:
I know it was you. You killed my mom. I saw what you did.
Henry trying to answer — it was an accident, I never meant—
The shove. Henry going backward. And then, not a decision, not a choice — something more fundamental than either, an instinctive barrier detonating outward when the body and mind hit a threshold simultaneously—
The boy's hands going to his face. Hitting the ground.
Henry's own expression, looking at what had happened, looking at his own hands.
Nevada. Everything Victor had carefully not said. Everything Virginia's fear had been made of.
And then the last scene, quieter and worse in some ways: Virginia on her knees in front of a younger Henry, her face marked with tears and something desperate that was still trying to look like calm, holding him while he came apart.
It was an accident, Mom. I didn't mean to—
I know. I know, baby. We're going to leave. We'll start somewhere new.
Patti sat on the attic floor in the middle of all this.
The radio was still in her hands.
She looked at it.
She understood, now, what it was connected to. Not her mother. Or — maybe her mother had been there for one moment, genuinely, the voice she'd heard had been real for one second before something else moved into the frequency and used the shape of it against both of them.
The thing that had answered her wasn't what she'd been calling for.
She also understood something else. Henry was losing. Whatever was fighting for control of him right now was winning, and the radio in her hands was part of how it was doing it.
She stopped hesitating.
She stood up, raised the radio over her head, and brought it down against the floor with everything she had.
The wooden casing cracked along the grain. One of the vacuum tubes shattered, the implosion making a sound like a small, cut-off cry. Static shrieked once, sharp and brief.
"Get out," Patti said, at the radio and at everything behind it and at this entire night. Her voice had the quality of something that had been through a lot and was done.
She raised what was left and brought it down again.
The casing came apart. Metal brackets skittered across the floor. The last connection failed with a sound like a sigh, and the static — the constant, omnipresent static that had filled the attic since she'd first stepped into it — went silent.
Entirely silent.
The absence of it was enormous.
Bob hit the attic doorway first, his flashlight sweeping before he'd fully stopped moving.
Henry was on his back in the dust. His eyes were shut, his body making small involuntary movements, the kind that happened when something had finished happening to a person and their system was trying to inventory the damage. His face was all wrong — tears and sweat mixed with dust, and the thin dark line of a nosebleed under his left nostril. He looked like something had taken him completely apart and reassembled him slightly wrong.
Principal Newby was in the far corner, slumped against a pile of old boxes. He was breathing — audible, labored, each inhale working at it. His eyes were open but not focused on anything in the room. His lips were moving.
Bob got close enough to hear fragments of it: ...have to help that boy... not his fault... save him... not his fault...
The words repeated without fully landing, like a record skipping.
The attic smelled like ozone and old burning and something biological. The candle had gone out at some point, and Bob's flashlight was the only light.
"Patty!" He swung the beam across the room, his voice cracking on the word.
A sound from the far corner, near the slanted wall.
Patti sat up from the floor with the careful movement of someone checking to make sure everything was still attached. Her face was white, her hair had come mostly loose, and there was a bruise beginning on her forehead. In her lap was a collection of shattered wood and twisted metal that had recently been a radio.
She looked at Bob. For a moment her eyes were somewhere far away, still partially in whatever she'd just come back from. Then they focused, and the first thing they moved to was her father in the corner.
"Dad." She got up fast, faster than she should have given how she'd been sitting, and crossed to Newby, crouching beside him and taking his hands. He looked up at her face and his lips kept moving but his eyes had something more present in them now.
"I need to tell you something."
Henry's voice. From the floor.
Weak, rough, like speaking cost him something he was running short of. But clear. Present. His eyes had opened, and the thing that looked out of them was Henry — not the other thing, not the absence, not the darkness. Just Henry, with the specific look of someone who had come back from somewhere bad and knew how much time he might have before it found him again.
His eyes found Patti's face and stayed there.
"I need to tell you—"
Patti wasn't listening. Or — she heard him, she heard every word, but the part of her that could respond to it was offline. What she needed right now, the only thing she could hold, was getting her father out of this room and herself out of this house and time to put the walls back up that tonight had taken down.
She got Newby upright, one arm across her shoulders, and started moving him toward the door. He was shaky but mobile, his feet finding the floor, one hand on the doorframe.
Joyce appeared in the doorway with Hopper right behind her, both of them taking in the room in the fast, cataloguing way people did when they came into a situation they hadn't seen the beginning of.
Patti moved past them without stopping, her father's weight on her shoulder, not looking back.
"Patti." Bob, behind her, urgent.
She didn't stop.
"Patti—"
The stairs took them. Her father's breathing steadied slightly as they moved. She kept her eyes on the hallway below, on the door, on the way out.
In the attic, the sound of their footsteps faded.
Hopper stood in the doorway, looking at Henry on the floor, at the destroyed radio, at Principal Newby's vacated corner. His face was doing the thing it did when he was working something out and hadn't reached a conclusion.
Joyce had crouched beside Henry, not touching him, just close enough to look at him properly.
Henry's arm had come up from the floor, reaching in the direction of the doorway where Patti had been. Then it came back down.
He was looking at the ceiling. At nothing. His chest moved up and down.
From his lips, barely audible, barely meant for anyone else:
"I'm sorry." A breath. "I'm not afraid." A breath. "I'm normal."
The words came in the cadence of something repeated so many times they'd worn their own groove. A formula, or what was left of one after the night had gotten done with it.
He said it again, lower, with a determination that had no business being as quiet as it was:
"I am Henry. I am Henry Creel."
The attic was still. The static was gone. Moonlight came through the broken blind in its thin pale lines, laying themselves across the floor the same way they always had, indifferent to everything that had happened underneath them.
Joyce looked at Hopper.
Hopper looked at Henry.
Nobody said anything for a while.
[500 PS unlocks 1 Extra Chapter]
[10 Reviews unlock 1 Extra Chapter]
Thanks for reading—reviews are appreciated.
P1treon Soulforger has 20+advance chapters