[Kara's Apartment — September 2017, 8:15 AM]
The eggs weren't burning.
Mon-El stared at the pan with something approaching disbelief. The scrambled eggs were actually scrambled—fluffy, golden, not the charred disaster of his previous attempts. The toast had emerged from the toaster at a reasonable color. The coffee—Kara's preferred blend, Ethiopian dark roast—steamed gently in its carafe.
He'd practiced. Three days of mornings at his old apartment, cooking and failing and cooking again until muscle memory took over. If today was the day everything changed, at least it would start with a decent breakfast.
Kara emerged from the bedroom, still sleepy, hair tousled in a way that made his chest ache. She stopped when she saw the spread on the table.
"What's the occasion?"
"I need to tell you something." He set down the spatula, wiping his hands on a towel. "Something real. Something I should have told you a long time ago."
Her expression shifted—curiosity sharpening into alertness. She knew him well enough to read the gravity in his voice.
"Okay." She crossed to the table, sat down slowly. "Should I be worried?"
"Maybe." Honesty. Start with honesty. "I don't know how you're going to react. I don't know if this is going to change everything or... or break everything." His voice cracked slightly on the last word. "But you deserve to know."
Kara studied him for a long moment, then reached across the table and took his hand. "Whatever it is—we'll face it together. That's what partners do."
He wanted to believe her. Wanted to trust that their bond was strong enough to survive what came next. But the weight of the secret pressed against his ribs, and he couldn't be certain of anything except that he couldn't carry it alone anymore.
"Eat first," he said. "Please. The eggs are actually edible this time."
---
They ate in near-silence. Mon-El forced himself to chew, to swallow, to perform the mechanics of a meal while his stomach churned. Kara watched him with those impossibly blue eyes, patient but clearly bracing herself.
When the plates were empty, he led her to the couch. Sat facing her. Took both her hands in his.
His heart hammered so loudly she could probably hear it—enhanced senses and all that. He wondered if she could smell his fear, taste the adrenaline in the air.
"Before I say anything," he began, "I need you to know that I love you. That's never been a lie. Everything I feel for you—that's real. Whatever else you learn today, please remember that."
"You're scaring me," Kara said quietly.
"I know. I'm sorry." He took a breath. Then another. His hands trembled in hers. "I'm not who you think I am."
She didn't pull away. Didn't flinch. Just waited, her grip steady, her presence an anchor.
"When I woke up in that pod—in the DEO cell—I wasn't... I wasn't the same person who got into it." The words came slowly, each one requiring effort. "I have memories of another life. Another world. A place that's nothing like Daxam. Nothing like here."
Kara's brow furrowed. "Another world? Like a parallel dimension?"
"Not exactly." This was the part he'd dreaded. The part that sounded insane no matter how he phrased it. "A world where this—all of this—was a story. A show. Something people watched for entertainment."
The confusion in her eyes deepened. "I don't understand."
"In my world—the world I remember—you're a character. Supergirl. A television show about a Kryptonian who comes to Earth and becomes a hero. I watched it. All of it. I know things about you that you never told me, because I saw them happen. On a screen. In another life."
Silence.
Kara's hands tightened around his, not pulling away but gripping harder, processing.
"You're saying..." She spoke carefully, as if testing each word. "You're saying that where you come from, I'm fictional? That my life is... entertainment?"
"Yes." The word tasted like ash. "I know how it sounds. I know it's impossible. But it's the truth."
"And you—you're not Mon-El? Not the prince who came to Earth in that pod?"
"I am and I'm not." He struggled to find the right explanation. "The body is his. The powers are his. But the consciousness, the memories, the person making decisions—that's me. Someone else. Someone who lived and died in another world and woke up here, in his body, with his life."
Kara was silent for a long moment. Her expression had gone distant, the way it did when she was working through something complex. Mon-El couldn't tell if that was good or terrible.
"How long?" she asked finally. "How long have you known?"
"Since the beginning. Since I opened my eyes in that cell."
"So everything—the interrogations, the training, learning about Earth, learning about me—"
"I already knew most of it. Some things were different. The timeline isn't exact. But the big events, the major beats... I knew."
Her hands trembled now, just slightly. "You knew about Mxyzptlk?"
"Yes."
"The Daxamite invasion?"
"Yes."
"My parents?"
His throat tightened. "Yes."
"And you never told me." Not accusation. Not yet. Just... observation.
"I didn't know how." He tightened his grip on her hands, desperate to maintain the connection. "At first I thought I was dreaming, or dead, or insane. Then I was surviving, trying to navigate a world I shouldn't exist in. And then..." He swallowed. "Then I fell in love with you. And I was terrified that telling you would destroy everything we'd built."
"So you lied."
"I withheld. I deflected. I told myself I was protecting you, protecting us. But yes." He met her eyes, refusing to look away from the judgment there. "I lied. By omission if not by commission. Every day. For almost a year."
Kara pulled her hands back. Not violently—gently, carefully, like she needed space to think. She stood, moved to the window, her back to him.
The silence stretched.
Mon-El's heart was breaking. Slowly, inevitably, like a building collapsing floor by floor.
"Keep going," she said finally, her voice barely audible.
"What?"
"You said you have memories of another world. A world where I'm a story." She turned to face him, and her eyes were wet but her jaw was set. "Tell me everything. I need to understand."
He took a breath. The hardest part was next.
"I watched your story, Kara. On a screen. In another life." The words came out rough, raw. "I know things about you that you never told me. Because where I'm from... you're not real."
Note:
Please give good reviews and power stones itrings more people and more people means more chapters?
My Patreon is all about exploring 'What If' timelines, and you can get instant access to chapters far ahead of the public release.
Choose your journey:
Timeline Viewer ($6): Get 10 chapters of early access + 5 new chapters weekly.
Timeline Explorer ($9): Jump 15-20 chapters ahead of everyone.
Timeline Keeper ($15): Get Instant Access to chapters the moment I finish writing them. No more waiting.
Read the raw, unfiltered story as it unfolds. Your support makes this possible!
👉 Find it all at patreon.com/Whatif0