Oliver parked his bike, kicking the stand down. He pulled the key Heather had given him from his pocket.
He was supposed to be meeting with his girlfriend to study. But he wanted to do a little more than that, it had been weeks since she had even put out because she had gotten so busy adjusting to their college courses and it was driving Oliver crazy.
As he walked inside he saw that it was empty. He walked up the steps thinking that Heather was probably in the shower but both the bathroom and her bedroom were empty. He sent her a quick text but he didn't get anything in return.
As Oliver was heading down the steps he heard whimpering. He froze confused and walked back up the stairs. He checked the bedroom again and could see there was still nobody there.
Oliver heard the whimpers continue and he followed them to Amy's door. Said door was cracked a little so he peeked his head inside. What he saw made his cock twitch in his jeans, excited by what he was seeing.
Amy laid in her bed with only a pair of white socks on, fingers inside her own pussy trying to pleasure herself. Oliver licked his lips at the sight, he reached down into his pants, biting his lip.
He rubbed himself listening to Amy's intoxicating moans. Oliver realized that he could get caught standing there masturbating to her perfect sounds but Oliver couldn't help himself.
He watched as Amy added two more fingers inside her pussy, whimpering. The whole thing caused Oliver to grow even harder as he stroked his hand up and down his shaft, he couldn't help but notice that she shaved down there. Licking his lips he found himself wanting to walk inside the room to just bend her over and fuck her. But he couldn't let himself do that so he stayed there wishing his hand was her mouth instead.
Oliver closed his eyes briefly picturing himself inside Amy and a smile came to his face. He didn't know why the idea of fucking his girlfriend's sister turned him on so bad but it did.
Oliver shook his head unable to believe just how perfect Amy's body looked. As he leaned a little too close to the door he fell inside, Amy quickly covered up. Her cheeks turned red, noticing that Oliver had his cock hanging out of his pants.
"Oliver" Amy said cheeks still red. She couldn't believe that Oliver had caught her doing that, she couldn't believe that he would be jerking off to her pleasuring herself. "What are you doing here?"
"I-" Oliver buttoned his pants back up, embarrassed. "I came to see Heather, where is she?"
"She had a last minute thing to do so I left campus without her" Amy replied. "So she's not going to be here for a while."
Oliver nodded. "I guess I'll wait downstairs—"
"I mean you can wait up here " Amy said, pulling herself from her bed exposing her body to Oliver. But this time it was different, she was happily showing him her body. "I don't mind but do you think Heather would?"
"We don't have to tell her" Oliver said closing the distance between them, sticking his finger inside her pussy. "This can just be our little secret. Can't it?"
Amy nodded. "I'm really good at keeping those."
"Are you?" Oliver smirked adding a second finger to her tight pussy. "I bet you're good at a lot of things."
Oliver grabbed her by the thighs lifting her, she wrapped her legs around his waist as she hungrily attacked his lips. He gently laid her down on the bed kissing her lips, never disconnecting until he started to tear his own clothes off. He threw his shirt to the floor and allowed his pants to stay at his ankles not really minding the feeling.
"I want to eat you out" Oliver bit his lip as he rubbed her clit causing a few moans to escape Amy's lips. "By the sound of it you want me to do it, too." Oliver dipped his fingers into her cunt deeper. "Come on baby. Use your words and tell me what you want me to do."
"I don't know if we should be doing this" Amy admitted as she started to come to her senses. "What if Heather finds out?"
"She's not going to find out" Oliver promised, digging his finger even farther in causing Amy to whimper. "I promise what we do today is just between us."
Amy gulped. She knew she should be pushing him away but there was just something about Oliver she couldn't deny. He wasn't the kind of guy she could say no to, there was something about him that just made her want to play against all the rules.
"Tell me what you want me to do" Oliver whispered against her neck. "What would you like me to do?"
"Eat me out" Amy said nervously. She knew it was silly to be this nervous but she couldn't help herself. She felt so awkward whenever Oliver was around her, even before today she had.
Oliver kissed her lips moving down to her neck, as he made it to her breasts he sucked hard on them. Licking all over them he wanted to shoot his load all over but he knew he was far from done so that would have to wait. They hadn't even started yet but he knew that's how he wanted to end it, with his release on Amy's chest. He gave them one final squeeze and lick before kissing down to her belly, leaving marks.
As he made it down to her pussy he rubbed it admiring how shaved she was. He grinned looking up at her. He stuck his finger inside feeling just how wet he was making her. He stroked his cock with his other hand, in awe of her pretty pussy and how wet it was.
He leaned his mouth closer to it, placing a finger inside. He touched her pussy with his tongue, licking the outer folds of it. He could tell that it was already starting to drive her crazy as he rammed his tongue inside her, licking deeper.
Amy closed her eyes taking it all in. The way his tongue collided with her folds felt like a brand new sensation she had been aching for. The way his tongue felt against her sensitive parts is what was causing her whimpers to increase as she begged for more.
"Oliver" She cried out, placing her hands in his dark coal like hair, tugging. "Your making me so wet."
Oliver roughly kissed her folds as his finger was still deep inside her. He licked up inside her cunt causing her to cry out and pull at his hair even harder.
Amy allowed herself to get lost as Oliver's tongue worked her cunt perfectly. She couldn't help it but she she came. Oliver let out a little chuckle before he started licking harder trying to get her to cum a second time. Amy felt it coming on again but she tried to keep herself in control. But she was finding it a little hard with how wet he was making her.
As she came a second time Oliver crawled back up to her so that they were face to face. He leaned over her grinning. The fact that he had already made her cum twice seemed to turn him on greatly.
"Oliver" Amy said placing her hands on the back of his neck, she was ready for him to be inside of her body already. "Will you fuck me?"
"I think you need to have a little patience first" Oliver said leaving trails of kisses down her chest.
"Oliver, please."
"I'm not going to fuck you until you suck my cock first" Oliver grinned down at her. "I want that pretty mouth to take all of it."
Amy was about to argue when Oliver grabbed her sides lifting her as he stood. He held her from her legs and she gasped at how he was holding her.
"Oliver!" Amy whimpered. "You could drop me.."
"I won't" Oliver promised. She couldn't see his face but she knew he had a grin plastered to it just by the way his voice had sounded.
"Oliver—"
"Come on suck it" Oliver chuckled. "Or you won't be able to take it in your pretty little cunt."
Amy gulped. "Just put me down first—"
"Oh I can't do that" Oliver teased. "You have to suck my dick in this position, baby. The quicker it's in your mouth then the quicker you get to feel it in your pussy."
Amy reached out stroking his cock the best way she could as being upside down wasn't the easiest way to do such a thing. She wanted to look up at him and give him a death glare for this but she couldn't even look up at him that well.
"The cock is waiting" Oliver laughed.
"Fuck you."
Amy put her mouth on it and Oliver thrusted his hips causing his cock to hit deeper into her mouth causing Amy to gag. "I'm going to fuck you so good."
Amy felt dizzy but kept her mouth on his cock trying to take as much as she possibly could. Once Oliver could tell she was getting a little too dizzy he gently laid her in the floor, Amy stroked his cock returning it inside her mouth.
Oliver placed his hand at the back of her head. He never thought that he could be doing any of this with his girlfriend's sister. He knew it was wrong but he didn't really care, he didn't give a shit as long as her mouth was on his cock.
"Yeah take that cock" Oliver said shoving his member into Amy's mouth deeper than before. "You look so pretty with my cock in your mouth."
His thrusting into her mouth was causing her to gag on the entire thing. Oliver knew he had to calm down before he caused her to choke on it. He pulled his cock out of her mouth as he let her catch her breath. He touched under her chin forcing her to stare up at him, he had a dark look in his eyes that just seemed to arouse Amy even more.
"I bet I suck it better than my sister does" Amy said rubbing up and down his shaft.
Oliver smiled, not denying the fact that she was probably right about that.
"So much fucking better" Oliver moaned. "You have a pretty little mouth. She never wants to suck me because she's scared she'll get choked.. "
Amy stood to her feet and wrapped her arms around Oliver's neck. "I bet I'm a better fuck, too."
Oliver picked her up, placing her down on his cock grinning. "I think you'll have to prove yourself."
Amy moaned, smiling as she felt him push up inside her. "Fuck."
Oliver grabbed her sides, standing against the wall as he pushed her up and down his cock. He could hear how wet her pussy was every time he slammed back up into her cunt.
"I can't believe it feels this good" Amy said whining at the contact. It was a perfect rhythm, she didn't even mind how fast he was going. It caused her to cum on his cock, this was the third time he had made her lose control. But it wasn't like she was complaining about it, she loved how big he felt inside her.
"I should have fucked you forever ago" Oliver admitted. "If I knew you could get this wet I would have done it a long time ago."
Amy's breasts pressed against Oliver's chest. Oliver wasn't massively ripped like most guys at the University but Amy actually liked that. She loved how natural his body felt against her own.
"Oliver, do you like my pussy?"
"Baby no I fucking love it" Oliver said moaning causing Amy to whimper and her tits to bounce as he pounded into her harder. "I love how wet you get for me. All I want is to make it mine."
"Yeah?" Amy moaned, taking all of it. Oliver simply nodded and Amy rubbed down his chest, gently. "I want you to make it yours too. I want you to do it right, do you think you can do that?"
Oliver didn't reply in words. Instead his response was laying onto the bed with himself on top. Without pulling out he pounded into her gaining moans from the beautiful blond under him. He leaned down capturing her lips with his own as he thrusted deep inside her, feeling the wetness of her pussy caused him to almost lose self control but he shook his head relaxing a bit before he started moving again.
He used his hands to press her legs far apart, grinning as he moved. "Baby you're so fucking flexible." Slamming into her over and over he couldn't get over how flexible he could make her be.
"Holy shit" Amy couldn't help it but she came again. Oliver's entire face broke out into a grin, loving the fact that he could hit a specific spot and she could just lose all self control without even meaning to. It caused him to grab the headboard of her bed and slam into her even harder than before. His speed seemed to increase and Amy wrapped her legs around his waist, taking him all in.
"Goddamn it" Oliver groaned pounding that specific spot yet again knowing he could easily make her cum. "How is it that your pussy can get so wet?"
"It's because it's what you do to me" She spit out as she tried to stay composed this time. "Nobody else could do this to me."
"Whenever I start staying over again" Oliver moaned slamming into her wet cunt, faster. "When Heather falls asleep I'm going to sneak into your room and fuck the shit out of you. I'm going to make you cum over and over just like I have today."
Amy bit her lip. "We'll have to be quiet so she doesn't hear us."
Oliver nodded. "That's true. But luckily she isn't here right now so I can make you fucking scream at the top of your lungs all I want." And with that he picked up the pace once again going at a speed he didn't think was possible as his hips adjusted. "I'm going to make you keep cumming on my dick."
"So am I better than my sister?"
"Fuck yeah " Oliver said snapping his hips pounding that spot that was causing her to scream and lose herself. The spot he absolutely loved to hit, the spot that was driving him fucking crazy.
He was going so fast that the bed was starting to pound against the wall. He knew if he didn't calm down he was going to be the cause of the wall getting a hole in it. But he still couldn't get himself to slow down, squeezing tight on her hips and slamming his cock deep inside, he moaned gripping tighter. Amy screamed unable to control herself anymore and she had came on his cock another time. But still Oliver didn't slow down, the bed still pounded against the wall.
He knew he didn't have much longer until he reached his release. But he had to make it last as long as he could so he slowed down his movements. He leaned down softly kissing Amy's lips, he moved to her neck sucking along it as he moved around inside Amy taking notice that Amy's moans had softened as well.
As he stared down into her eyes he couldn't help but feel like he never wanted this to end.
"So fucking perfect" Oliver smiled. "Every fucking inch of you is so fucking perfect, Ame."
Oliver grabbed her waist rolling them leaving himself to be on the bottom and allowing Amy to now be on top. Amy felt a little impressed that he didn't even have to pull out to make that happen.
Oliver grabbed her sides, working in a rhythm as Amy started catching up to this rhythm. She laid her hand on his chest, taking notice of the fact that Oliver was already trying to increase the speed that they were moving in.
"So much better than your sister's pussy" Oliver said pulling her along his cock, watching as Amy's tits bounced perfectly.
"Oliver" Amy whimpered as Oliver ran his hand through her blond hair, hitting her spot as she rode perfectly. "I don't think that I can handle much more."
"So fucking wet and ready for me" Oliver moaned, slapping her ass cheeks hard as he left red marks all across them. "I could just cum inside you, it's what you would deserve for being such a naughty girl and fucking your sister's boyfriend."
"Oliver, please" Amy was begging knowing that she was close to her release yet again. But she knew this time she wouldn't be able to keep going.
Their skin slapped together roughly. Amy was losing control and Oliver wasn't that far behind. He knew he didn't have much longer to go until he came, he wanted to pound into her as long as he possibly could.
As he felt her cum around him one final time he knew he couldn't hang on any longer so he pulled out of her. He laid her down and stroked his cock knowing where he wanted to release it, he held his length above her breasts stroking it as it came through all over her chest.
Oliver fell down laying next to her. He was about to say something when they heard the front door slam. They shared a look as they heard a familiar voice calling for Amy.
Oliver hid under the bed as Amy pulled a night shirt on. She kicked Oliver's clothes into a corner just in time as Heather pulled her head inside. "Hey I'm sorry to interrupt but did Oliver come by?"
"Yeah" Amy said nodding. "He said something about needing you to meet him at the library."
"Thanks" Heather said smiling but then she felt confused. "I guess he decided to walk to the library because his bike is still outside."
"He didn't want to waste any gas" Amy lied. "You know how he is, Heather."
Amy felt relieved once Heather was gone and Oliver climbed out putting his hands up her night shirt. "I am not going to the Goddamn library."
Amy kissed his lips as Oliver picked her up deepening the kiss. At that moment Amy knew things were just going to get even more crazy and complicated.
----------------------------------------------------------
Tori felt nervous to be alone with Matthew in his room because she knew that it was a pretty bad idea. After almost kissing him last year at Hailey's party it was a very stupid idea to be alone with him.
But she had promised Matthew that she would help him prepare for finals and she couldn't back out now and let him down.
"So I think I'm done" Matthew said feeling nervous. "But I don't know if I got everything right."
Tori grabbed his paper and she looked it over before she started to nod. "It's good. It's better than before. I think you're going to do just fine, Matty."
"Thanks" Matthew smiled. "I'm really glad you came over and helped. I don't know what I would do without you." He stood up and pulled Tori into his arms as he hugged her.
Tori closed her eyes as she placed her hands on his back. She tried to not admire the muscles in it but it was hard to not.
She tried to remind herself that Hailey was her best friend and that her friendship with Hailey meant everything to her.
She also tried to remind herself that Matthew was Eddie's best friend and it wouldn't be fair to him.
But Tori couldn't seem to get ahold of herself as she let her hands stay there admiring how perfectly muscular the boy was.
Matthew looked into Tori's eyes and he licked his lips before he started to smile. "I'm really happy you're here, Tori."
"I should go" Tori tried to have self-control. "I shouldn't be here."
"Don't go" Matthew begged. "I want you here."
"Matthew, you know what I want" Tori whispered. "You know how badly I want you and if I stay here I'm going to wish this was more."
Matthew smiled. "Maybe it can be more, Tor. Maybe I can give you what you've always been asking me for."
"What about Hailey and Eddie?"
"We don't have to tell them" Matthew told her. "We can be together in secret and they'll never have to know."
"I don't want to hurt them, Matthew..."
"Neither do I" Matthew replied. "But I know what I want and what I want is you, Tori."
Tori gently grabbed on Matthew's neck as she brought his lips down to her own. Matthew's hands traveled down to her waist as their kissing became desperate and needy.
Tori felt pathetic because of how much she felt that she needed him but she didn't care. If this was a one time thing then she was going to make the most of it.
"Tor, I want to see your tits so bad" Matthew was begging. Tori could feel how hard he had gotten against her. "Please show me them."
Tori felt nervous but she nodded. "Okay." She watched as Matthew laid on his bed and licked his lips as he waited for his prize to be unhidden.
Tori found the courage by reminding herself this could be her only chance to be with Matthew and so she had to make the most of it.
She pulled her dress down and slipped out of it. She then grabbed the back of the bra as she stared at Matthew.
Once she had it unhooked she tossed the bra in Matthew's face and at first she feared it had gone too far but he started to laugh.
Matthew sat up and pulled Tori onto his lap with a smile spread across his face. "You are so fucking hot." He took in how perfect her breasts looked and he put one in his mouth as he sucked on it causing Tori to pull at his dark hair and moan.
"Matthew, fuck!" Tori gasped unable to believe he had her tit in his mouth. "This can't be real. This has to be a dream-"
Matthew pulled the tit from his mouth with a pop and he grinned. "It's not a dream, Tori. And thank God it isn't cause goddamn." He grabbed Tori's waist as he caused her to grind against him. "I could cum in my pants right now."
"Don't" Tori begged. "I want it inside me."
Matthew grew even harder at the possibility of leaving a creampie inside of Tori. "You want my cum inside you?"
"I was actually just talking about your dick" Tori felt turned on by the idea of having Matthew's semen inside her but she also felt worried. "I mean I'm not sure if you cumming in me would be smart."
"I want to" Matthew admitted. "I want to bust my load in your pretty pussy so fucking bad."
Tori felt unsure about letting him give her a creampie. "I never even let Eddie give me creampies, Matty..."
"Then it will be something special for us" Matthew smiled, happily. "Only something you and I get to do together."
The thought of sharing something special only with Matthew seemed to only make Tori even wetter. "Do you promise I'll be the only girl you put your creampies in?"
"Oh, I promise" Matthew swore. "I'll save all the creampies for you, Tori."
Tori blushed, deciding that this was her one chance to feel his cum inside her and she had to take it. "Okay..."
Matthew smiled and he tossed her aside so he could stand up. He reached for Tori's panties and he slowly pulled them off as he left kisses on her thighs. He could tell how nervous Tori was getting and he shook his head.
"Don't worry" Matthew soothed her. "Nobody will know except for us."
Tori nodded and closed her eyes as she could feel Matthew's tongue pressing against her slit. Her hands gripped the sheets beneath her as she tried to hold in her moans, terrified that Matthew's parents would hear.
Matthew worked his tongue in deeper and he could tell that it was driving her crazy but still he added a finger.
"Matthew" Tori moaned as quietly as she could. "You're going to make me cum."
Matthew hummed in response and licked her folds before he came up for air. But he added two more fingers and grinned. "You're so fucking wet."
"I can't help it" Tori admitted. "I've always wanted you, Matty."
"I've always wanted to fuck you" Matthew grinned as he started to move his fingers at a quickened pace causing the girl to moan. "I would picture how fucking hot your moans would fucking sound and trust me... what I thought it sounded like isn't as fucking good as the real thing."
Tori covered her mouth as she tried to quiet down.
"You don't have to be quiet" Matthew told her as he pulled his fingers out and then pushed them back in but this time even deeper. "I don't care who hears, Tori. You can be as fucking loud as you want."
"Matthew, your parents will hear us" Tori moaned. "I don't want them to hear us."
Matthew shrugged as his fingers dug deeper causing Tori to scream. "It doesn't matter. I do whatever the fuck I want to do."
Tori couldn't stop herself and she came all over Matthew's fingers. "Matthew, OH!"
Matthew got to his feet and pulled his shirt off before he tossed it in Tori's face to throwback to how she had done the same which only caused Tori to giggle. She then watched as Matthew tore his jeans off and once he kicked those off she started to bite her lip as Matthew slowly took off his boxers and once he had the cock free all Tori could do was foam at the mouth.
She didn't think she had ever seen a more perfect cock in her entire life and all she wanted was for it to be inside her already.
"Not yet" Matthew said as if he was reading her mind. "I want you to suck it first."
Tori nodded and got off the bed before she dropped to her knees. She explored it first and traced every part of it with her fingers. She looked up at him and Matthew's fingers rubbed her chin as he started to grin.
"Do it, Tori. Make my cock feel even happier..."
So Tori took the whole thing in her mouth she got choked and quickly had to pull it back out. "Fuck."
Matthew chuckled. "You can start out slow if you want to."
Tori found her courage and slowly put the head of Matthew's cock back in her mouth. She explored it before she started to slowly take a little bit more.
"Tori" Matthew moaned. "You have such a perfect mouth. I swear."
Tori managed to work her way to taking every inch and she moved back and forth taking it as she bobbed her head. She could feel Matthew's fingers in her hair and she could feel him pushing her back on it each time she'd move backwards and all it did was make Tori get even wetter so she started to finger herself.
"Yeah play with yourself, baby" Matthew grinned. "Add another finger."
So Tori did.
When Tori added a third finger she could feel herself go and all it did was make her want Matthew's creampie in her even more.
"Do you want my cock in you now?"
Tori licked up and down Matthew's cock unable to believe how tasty it was. But when she looked up at Matthew he could tell that she was ready to feel him inside her and Matthew felt relieved because he needed to be buried deep in her pretty pussy already.
He jerked Tori up and then their lips met briefly. He pulled Tori onto the bed with him and he climbed on top before he placed his dick at her entrance and then he started to bury himself as deeply inside her as he could get.
"Matthew" Tori gasped at how full she felt with him inside and she could tell his cock wasn't fully in her yet. "Oh my god. I don't know if I can take all of it."
"Don't worry" Matthew grinned. "You will." And with that he pushed his cock the rest of the way in causing Tori to yelp. "Fuck. You are so fucking wet."
Tori moaned. "Matthew, oh my god."
"Can I start moving?"
"Okay" Tori said in a small, nervous voice. "Just don't be too-" Matthew thrusted roughly into her and she cried out. "-rough!!"
Matthew kissed her lips as he tried to quiet down her moans as he rocked his body into hers. "Tori, you're getting my dick so fucking wet."
Tori stared up in Matthew's eyes and she could see the hunger in them. She couldn't believe how badly he wanted her and all that did was convince her to open up more to him and she wrapped her legs around his waist as he got even deeper.
"Matthew!" Tori whined. "Oh my god!!"
"You like that cock?"
"Yeah" Tori moaned. "It feels so good." She shrieked as she felt Matthew's cock hitting her G-spot and her nails found his muscular back as she dug deep. "You're going to make me cum, Matty."
"Fucking do it" Matthew begged. "I want you to cum all over my cock, babygirl."
"I-" Tori couldn't think as she felt Matthew thumbing her slit and she let her nails dig even deeper in the muscles in his back as she let herself go. "Matty-I can't-"
"It's okay, Tori" Matthew grinned. "Fucking do it." He hit her G-spot once more and that got Tori to go and she cried out as she did.
But she knew it was far from over.
"Matthew-"
"We aren't fucking done yet" Matthew grinned. "I want you to fucking ride on top." And with that he flipped them over and because his dick had been pulled out all he did was grab Tori's waist and push her back down on his cock.
Tori gasped. "Matty!"
"Ride."
Tori felt a little self-conscious but she had dreamed about this and so she wasn't about to deny Matthew or herself so she placed her hand on his chest as she started to move along his cock. Matthew grabbed her waist and he started to grin.
"Just like that" Matthew licked his lips. "Take that fucking cock."
"It feels so good" Tori admitted. "I love your body, Matthew."
Matthew roughly pulled on her waist as their movements sped up and all he could focus on was Tori's titties as they jumped all over the place.
"Matty, oh my god" Tori cried out. "You're going to get me there too fucking soon again."
Matthew didn't care and he grabbed her breasts, squeezing. "Good. As soon as you cum so will I."
Tori smiled down at him and giggled. "Oh, you going to give me that creampie?"
"Fuck yeah" Matthew grinned. "As soon as you cum for me."
Tori cried out as she felt Matthew getting deeper and she let her nails dig into Matthew's abs, knowing that she didn't have long with how hard Matthew's cock was hammering against her G-spot and she leaned down as her tits pressed against his muscular chest.
Tori kissed his lips as she went and then Matthew was fucking into her hard from below as he knew he was only a few seconds away from giving her every drop of his semen.
"Oh my god-" Tori cried out against his lips. "I can't-I-"
And that's when Matthew let himself go and he could feel every drop go inside her and all he could do was grin. He pulled Tori's lips back to his own and he knew he should feel shame and regret but he didn't.
If anything all he wanted was to fuck her again.
It seemed Tori wasn't opposed to that either because she was laying her sweaty body against his refusing to move.
"Let's maybe not tell Hailey and Eddie about this" Tori said, quietly. "This can just be something between us..."
Matthew grinned. "Agreed."