Chapter 37: THE MEETING
The Wheeler basement smelled like old carpet and teenage anxiety.
I followed Max down the stairs, acutely aware of the eyes tracking our descent. Four boys arranged in what they probably thought was a defensive formation—Mike Wheeler at the center, Lucas flanking left, Dustin on the right, and Will standing slightly apart, watching with those pale, distant eyes that told me the Mind Flayer's influence was already deeper than I'd hoped.
Two days since I'd told Max the truth. Two days of planning, of figuring out how to approach this without getting rejected before I could explain. Max had insisted on handling the setup—she knew these kids, understood their dynamics, could navigate the politics of their little group better than I could.
Now we were here. And from the hostile expressions facing me, the navigation was going to be tricky.
"Why would you bring him here?" Mike demanded, stepping forward with the aggressive confidence of a kid who'd never been hit by someone who meant it. "He hates us. He's Max's psycho stepbrother."
"He doesn't hate you," Max said, positioning herself between me and the group. "And he's not a psycho. Just... different."
"Different how?" Lucas had shifted his weight, ready to move. Protecting Max, even from me. I filed that away—the crush I'd observed at the arcade had developed into something more substantial. Good. She deserved someone who'd stand up for her.
"Different like this." Max turned to me. "Show them, Billy."
The moment of truth. I'd rehearsed this in my head a dozen times, tried to figure out the best way to introduce fire powers to a group of middle schoolers who'd already fought interdimensional monsters. In the end, I'd decided on simplicity.
I raised my palm and let the fire bloom.
Orange light filled the basement, dancing shadows across the walls, illuminating faces frozen in various stages of shock. The flame was controlled—barely more than a candle, really—but the effect was undeniable.
"HOLY SHIT!" Dustin stumbled backward, knocking into a shelf of board games. Something clattered to the floor. "He's—that's—holy shit!"
Mike's mouth opened, closed, opened again. No words came out. His hand reached for something at his belt—a walkie-talkie, probably, his connection to whoever else was in their network.
Lucas moved instantly, positioning himself between me and Max with the instincts of someone who'd learned to protect people he cared about. "Get behind me."
"Lucas, I'm fine—"
"He has fire hands!"
"I know. I've known for months." Max pushed past him, joining me at the center of the room. "This is what I've been trying to tell you. Billy's not what you think. He's been preparing for something—something connected to what happened to Will last year."
Will.
I'd been watching him since we entered, tracking his reactions. While the others panicked and postured, Will had done something different. He'd stepped forward. Closer to the fire. Closer to me.
"You're warm," he said softly. "Like fire inside. I can feel it."
The basement went quiet. Everyone turned to look at the pale boy who'd been standing apart, who'd been absent even when present, who carried something cold inside him that none of them fully understood.
"Yeah," I said, meeting his eyes. "And you're cold. I can feel that too."
Will's expression flickered—fear, recognition, something that might have been hope. "You know what's happening to me?"
"I know enough." I extinguished the flame in my palm, but the warmth remained. "I know about the Upside Down. The Demogorgon. The Lab. Your... condition." I looked at each of them in turn. "I know a lot of things I shouldn't know. And I'm here because whatever's coming, we're going to need all the help we can get."
The kids exchanged glances. That silent communication that groups develop over time, the shorthand of shared experience and trust.
"How?" Mike demanded, finding his voice at last. "How do you know any of this? You just moved here."
"Does it matter?" I reached into my jacket pocket and pulled out the Polaroid photos—the charred earth at the quarry, the distinctive pattern of a burned body. "Two nights ago, something attacked me. One of those dog things—Demo-dogs, I've been calling them. Smaller than the Demogorgon, but related. It came out of the dark and tried to kill me."
Dustin grabbed the photos, examining them with the intensity of someone who'd spent too much time thinking about monsters. "These burn patterns... this is thermal damage way beyond normal fire. You did this?"
"Phase 3. Takes everything I've got, but it works." I tapped the photo in his hands. "Fire kills them. That's what I bring to the table."
"Wait—wait." Dustin's eyes widened, and I could see the connections forming in his brain. "The quarry. A few weeks ago. I was out biking and I saw... I saw fire. In the quarry. It was you!"
"Wondered when you'd put that together."
"I KNEW IT!" He spun to face the others. "I told you guys I saw something! You said it was probably just kids with fireworks!"
"It usually is kids with fireworks," Mike said defensively.
"Well this time it was a guy who can shoot actual fire from his hands!" Dustin turned back to me, practically vibrating with excitement. "How does it work? Is it biological? Psychological? Do you have to concentrate or is it automatic? What's the temperature range? Can you—"
"Dustin." Lucas put a hand on his shoulder. "Breathe."
"Right. Breathing. But seriously—"
"Later." I moved past them, toward Will. The pale boy hadn't retreated when I approached, hadn't flinched from the heat that radiated off me even with the fire extinguished. "You said you could feel my warmth. Does it help? Being near it?"
Will considered the question with the seriousness of someone who'd learned not to dismiss strange experiences. "I don't know. Maybe. The cold... it's always there now. But when you lit the fire, it felt... less."
The Mind Flayer. Already establishing its grip, already spreading its influence through the connection Will couldn't close. Heat was its weakness—the show had made that clear. If proximity to my fire could offer even temporary relief...
"Then stick close to me when you can," I said. "I don't know if it'll help long-term, but it can't hurt."
"Why should we trust you?" Mike had recovered his composure, that suspicious intensity back in full force. "You show up with fire powers and convenient knowledge and expect us to just accept it? For all we know, you're working with the Lab."
Fair question. I would have asked the same thing in his position.
"Because Max trusts me," I said simply. "And she knows you better than I do. If she thought I was a threat, she wouldn't have brought me here."
Max stepped forward. "He's telling the truth. Whatever Billy is now—whatever changed him before we moved here—he's on our side. I've seen it. Lived with it. He's not the person the rumors say he is."
The basement fell silent again. The boys looked at each other, at Max, at me. Making calculations, weighing risks and rewards, trying to decide if the enemy of their enemy could be trusted.
Finally, Mike spoke. "If you know about the Upside Down, you know about El."
Eleven. The girl with powers, the girl who'd closed the Gate, the girl Hopper was protecting somewhere in the woods.
"I know she exists," I said carefully. "I don't know where she is, and I'm not asking. That's your secret to keep."
Something shifted in Mike's expression. Respect, maybe. The recognition that I wasn't trying to learn more than I needed to.
"Okay," he said. "We're not saying we trust you. But we're listening."
It was a start.
Leaving the Wheeler house an hour later, my head was full of new information. The kids had shared what they knew—Will's episodes, the drawings, their suspicions about the tunnel system spreading beneath Hawkins. In return, I'd given them details about my encounter with the Demo-dog, about the wrongness I sensed near the lab, about my training at the quarry.
An alliance. Fragile, tentative, but real.
Max was grinning as we walked to the Camaro. "That went better than expected."
"Dustin's going to ask a million questions."
"Probably." She climbed into the passenger seat. "But he's smart. They all are. They survived last year."
"Yeah." I started the engine, thinking about the pale boy who'd sensed my fire, about the cold he carried inside him, about the battle that was coming whether any of us were ready. "Let's hope we survive this year too."
Note:
Please give good reviews and power stones itrings more people and more people means more chapters?
My Patreon is all about exploring 'What If' timelines, and you can get instant access to chapters far ahead of the public release.
Choose your journey:
Timeline Viewer ($6): Get 10 chapters of early access + 5 new chapters weekly.
Timeline Explorer ($9): Jump 15-20 chapters ahead of everyone.
Timeline Keeper ($15): Get Instant Access to chapters the moment I finish writing them. No more waiting.
Read the raw, unfiltered story as it unfolds. Your support makes this possible!
👉 Find it all at patreon.com/Whatif0