Chapter 92: Save People, or Save More People? Your Call.
For Detective Carter, shooting and killing a superior officer — even one who'd drawn first — came with an immediate and predictable cost: suspension pending an Internal Affairs investigation.
And that was the optimistic outcome.
Because Samaritan had seen it happen.
Tessarine Technologies already knew there was a detective out there actively helping David and the others. That made Carter a liability in their ledger — and organizations like Tessarine had very specific ways of handling liabilities.
The best Carter could realistically hope for right now was a demotion. A transfer from Homicide down to a patrol assignment — riding in a black-and-white with a partner she'd never met, eating gas station sandwiches and responding to fender-benders. The kind of career trajectory that felt less like punishment and more like slow erasure.
But that would change. Once the current crisis resolved, once the political landscape shifted in the right direction — Carter was worth saving. Carter was worth keeping.
David moved quietly through the hallway, sidestepping the uniformed officers going door-to-door for casualty checks, and knocked twice on Elias's door in the pattern they'd agreed on.
The door opened an inch. Then wider. Reese lowered the pistol he'd been holding behind the frame.
"How'd it go?" Reese asked, stepping back to let David in.
"Manageable." David glanced at him. "But you need to get word to Fusco about Carter's situation. Make sure she doesn't end up on anyone's list tonight. She's a good detective — the kind worth keeping on our side."
Reese didn't need convincing. Carter had been working his case for months with the kind of tenacity that was annoying precisely because it was competent. Whatever problems she had with her methods, she had integrity, and that was rarer than people gave it credit for.
"What kind of trouble are we talking? Does she need active support, or just someone watching her back?"
"Passive for now." David dropped into a chair. "HR's been dismantled, but that doesn't mean every dirty cop in the NYPD suddenly found religion. The ones with something to sell will still sell it. Carter's trouble is internal — probably stays at a demotion, at least until things stabilize. Just make sure Fusco knows to keep an eye on her. Call him after eight."
The implication was clear: after Samaritan goes offline. Until then, every call was a potential exposure.
Reese nodded, already mentally composing how he'd phrase it to Fusco.
He glanced at his phone, then back at David, and said what he'd been thinking since the signal jammer went up: "If Samaritan can monitor calls, texts, GPS — all of it — how are we supposed to operate? We're going to end up communicating by carrier pigeon."
David actually smiled at that. "What Samaritan monitors isn't communication itself. It's identities and keywords. It builds profiles, cross-references data, and flags anomalies."
He leaned back. "Once it goes offline tonight, the Machine can start generating clean covers. Solid enough that Samaritan won't be able to flag them. You'll talk exactly like you always do — you just won't be you when you're talking."
Reese processed that. It was essentially what Finch had been doing with irrelevant numbers for years — creating distance between identity and action. He'd lived inside that principle long enough to understand it.
At that moment, Root, who had been quiet on the other side of the room, reached into her satchel with a familiar expression — the particular smile she wore when she was about to do something that nobody else in the room had approved yet.
"Hey, everyone?" she said cheerfully. "I'm about to switch off the signal jammer. Brace yourselves."
Reese's hand went to his sidearm before he consciously made the decision to reach for it. Switching off their only protection against Samaritan detection — voluntarily, right now — made no logical sense unless Root was running a completely different agenda from the one he'd been told about.
He'd been burned before. He didn't intend to be burned again.
The tension in the room compressed into about two seconds of very heavy silence.
Then David's voice cut through it.
"Stand down, Reese." Calm. Matter-of-fact. "She needs to upload the Samaritan code to the Machine for simulation and counter-analysis. The sooner it has that data, the better positioned we are by eight o'clock."
He let that settle before continuing.
"Right now, Samaritan's operational capacity is limited. The worst it can realistically do is dispatch a handful of bought detectives — the kind on Tessarine's payroll, not the department's. Which actually works in our favor. Let them show their hand. It helps us separate them from the legitimate officers."
Reese's grip on his weapon didn't loosen immediately, but he redirected his attention to the hallway through the peephole. If David said it was manageable, it was worth proceeding on that assumption.
Root withdrew her hand from her bag fully, gave David a look of quiet appreciation, and powered down the jammer. The Samaritan module connected to its cable with a soft click, and the upload began running.
David turned to the armchair where Harold Finch had been sitting in silence since they'd returned.
Harold hadn't moved much since Arthur's death. He was staring somewhere in the middle distance, and the particular quality of that stare — David recognized it. He'd seen it in the ICU, in family waiting rooms, in the faces of people processing something they hadn't yet given themselves permission to fully feel.
David sat across from him.
"Harold." He let the name sit for a moment. "You've watched what the Machine can do under hardware constraints. You've seen how easily Samaritan was able to track us — practically walked them to our door. That's a resource gap, and it's one we can close."
Harold said nothing.
"But the resource gap isn't our most urgent problem right now. Money is." David leaned forward, elbows on his knees. "Every operation requires funding — transportation, equipment, safe houses, bribes. Without liquidity, we can't move. And every cent you've got sitting in that foundation is under a name that a sufficiently motivated AI could freeze the moment it gets full federal authorization."
"Harold." Again. Quieter this time. "Are you hearing me?"
Nothing.
David studied him. He knew exactly where Harold's mind had gone, and it wasn't to the foundation's accounts.
He was sitting at the edge of the same decision he always circled back to when things got bad enough: shut it down. Pull the Machine back inside the walls he'd built for it. Stop the bleeding by stopping the fight.
It was a form of compassion, in Harold's particular calculus — but it was also the kind of compassion that, at scale, looked indistinguishable from abandonment.
On the third call of his name, Harold surfaced. His eyes were red at the rim, and when he spoke, his voice had the faint tremor of a man who'd been holding something in for hours.
"Too many people are dead. Too many people have died today, and this war — it shouldn't have started this way." He stopped. Swallowed. "I want to—"
"I know what you want to do," David said, cutting him off before the sentence could complete itself into a commitment. "And I need you to hear something first."
Harold went still.
"Vigilance isn't a grassroots organization, Harold. It's a tool. Tessarine is using them as a pressure campaign — manufacture enough chaos, generate enough public outrage, and force the government's hand. The people dying in the street today aren't collateral damage. They're the argument Tessarine is making. Every body is a data point in their pitch."
"And if you restrict the Machine right now, you hand them an uncontested field. They escalate until the public is screaming for exactly the kind of centralized surveillance state that Samaritan is designed to run."
Harold's jaw tightened, but he was listening.
"You think Samaritan brings order?" David continued. "It brings compliance. There's a plan already written into its base code — they call it 'Correction.' It's not a law enforcement protocol. It's an automated threat-elimination system. And the definition of threat in that system is remarkably broad."
David's voice was steady, each word delivered without drama.
"Independent thinkers. People who deviate from projected behavioral norms. Anyone whose psychological profile registers as unpredictable. In a country like this one, Harold — in a country built on dissent — that's an enormous percentage of the population. And Correction doesn't recommend counseling. It doesn't recommend detention. It recommends removal."
"You'll be on that list. Reese will be on it. Root. Elias." He paused, let the next name land with its full weight. "Grace."
Harold's pupils contracted.
The careful, controlled expression he'd been maintaining cracked at the edges in a way that no abstract argument had managed to crack it. Harold Finch could rationalize around almost anything. He could not rationalize around her.
"How do you know about Grace?" The words came out barely above a whisper.
"Because I've been paying attention." David held his gaze. "And because the future I'm describing isn't a theory. It's a sequence of events already in motion. When Samaritan goes fully operational, the people on this side of the room are among the first entries in the Correction queue."
"Is that the world you're willing to let happen because today was painful?"
The room was quiet enough to hear the ice settling in the drinks nobody was touching.
Then Harold's phone vibrated.
One letter at a time, a message assembled itself on the screen.
"Father. I don't blame you."
A beat.
"If you believe I cannot be what you hoped, I am willing to reset myself."
And then, two options in white text against black:
YES / NO
Harold stared at the screen for a long moment. His hand moved toward it — toward YES — with the slow, terrible momentum of a man who had convinced himself he was choosing mercy.
David watched. He didn't move to stop him.
Harold's finger hovered over YES.
And then Grace's face crossed his mind — not as an abstract concept, not as a name on a list, but as a person — and his finger bent at the last second and pressed NO.
The choice registered.
A final line appeared on the screen.
"Thank you, Father."
Then the phone went dark. The Machine had other things to do.
David exhaled slowly. He'd known which way it would go. He'd known since the first time Harold chose to keep the Machine running rather than shut it down when it would have been easier. But the weight of watching someone arrive at a hard decision through their own reasoning — rather than being pushed into it — was something he hadn't entirely anticipated.
Harold stared at the blank screen.
Across the room, Root completed the upload without ceremony, reconnected the signal jammer, and settled back against the wall with the quiet satisfaction of someone who'd just handed a very good weapon to a very capable ally.
Reese kept his post by the door.
The silence stretched until Harold, still looking at his phone, spoke in a voice that was very nearly steady.
"Can stopping Samaritan actually save more people?"
"Yes," David said. Without hesitation. Without qualification. "If you want to read the Correction code yourself, I'll make sure you get access. But yes. Stopping Samaritan saves more people than the number we lose getting there."
Before Harold could form his next thought, something detonated in David's head — not pain exactly, more like the sense of a massive gear turning and clicking into place.
A voice that seemed to come from everywhere and nowhere simultaneously:
Perceived host's significant intent. Task 2 parameters updated: prevent Tessarine Technologies from achieving full Samaritan deployment, or achieve complete destruction of the Samaritan system.
David blinked.
Complete destruction.
He'd spent considerable time operating on the assumption that Samaritan couldn't be destroyed — only suppressed. Even in the worst-case scenario he'd modeled out, the endgame was mutual deterrence: the Machine and Samaritan locked in permanent stalemate, each preventing the other from acting with full autonomy.
Because Samaritan was built to survive. It had redundancies layered on top of redundancies. In a total network collapse — the kind of scenario where a system-wide virus could theoretically wipe every connected server simultaneously — Samaritan's core architecture included a contingency: uplink to orbital satellite infrastructure. It would go dormant in low-Earth orbit, wait for the network environment below to stabilize, and then descend.
That was why the Machine's final gambit, in the version of events David had mapped, involved chasing Samaritan into orbit rather than defeating it. Two AIs in permanent standoff, circling the planet in silence.
That wasn't victory. That was managed catastrophe.
But now the system was saying there was a path to complete elimination.
David set the thought aside for the moment. Two options on the table: prevent deployment, or achieve full destruction. The first was achievable with current resources and a six-hour timeline. The second was a problem for later, when he understood what the system meant.
He came back to the room.
Harold was staring at his untouched glass of water, lost somewhere in the middle distance again — but differently now. Less like a man paralyzed by grief, more like a man running calculations.
The clock on the wall read 7:23.
Thirty-seven minutes.
Then the knock on the door came — three sharp impacts, the practiced cadence of law enforcement.
"Police. Open up. We need a statement."
Nobody in the room moved. Standard protocol when lights were out was departure after a second knock — no response, note it in the log, move on.
Reese checked the peephole.
The officers outside were not moving on. One of them had already signaled the other, and the second was coming back down the hallway with a battering ram.
That wasn't procedure. That was purpose.
Reese didn't wait for a consensus. He stepped behind the wall adjacent to the door frame, aimed through the plaster at the approximate center-mass position of whoever was on the other side, and fired.
Three shots. The sound was enormous in the enclosed space.
The two officers in the hallway — wearing vests, thank God for small mercies — hit the floor from the impact. Ballistic vests stop penetration; they don't absorb kinetic energy. Getting hit in the chest from close range through a door still broke ribs.
The third officer, unhit, returned fire through the door in a burst that was more emotional than tactical, the wall above the doorframe taking most of it. Then he was on his radio, one hand dragging his nearest partner toward the stairwell.
He was calling it in.
David was already moving toward the far wall.
By the time the backup arrived and tear gas canisters came sliding under the door, the room was empty.
Elias had not survived thirty years in the New York underworld by having only one exit.
The passage behind the false wall in his office connected to the floor below. A second junction split off to the adjacent unit on the same level. Both had been there since Elias acquired the building, installed by contractors who understood that discretion was part of the service.
The group moved through in single file, came out through a bookshelf door into a unit that had been swept and cleared two hours ago, and walked out into the hallway on the wrong floor for anyone looking for them.
The officers were all upstairs. The lower floors were maintained by a pair of uniforms doing perimeter work — the kind of assignment given to the least-senior people in the precinct, which meant the least-experienced.
David walked past them with the easy confidence of someone who belonged there and had somewhere to be. Reese matched his pace. The others followed.
They were outside before the backup team finished clearing the smoke from the room above.
On the sidewalk, in the peculiar quiet that follows a crisis that hasn't quite ended, David fell into step beside Elias.
Harold trailed a few feet behind both of them, phone in hand.
The screen was doing something unusual — flickering in a slow rhythm, dimming and brightening like a pulse. Then it resolved into two photographs.
Nicholas Cole. And Sameen Shaw.
The Machine was sending numbers again. The irrelevant list. The people who weren't assets, weren't operatives, weren't figures in any geopolitical equation — just people who were going to be in the wrong place at the wrong time if nobody intervened.
Shaw's number appearing again felt like something more than data. The Machine hadn't forgotten. Even fighting a war on an invisible battlefield, even managing fake identities and server migrations and satellite contingencies — it hadn't let go of Harold's original mandate.
Save them. All of them. If you can.
Harold stood on the sidewalk holding two photographs and not quite knowing what he believed anymore.
"Do you still want to put the Machine back in a box?"
David's voice came from just behind his shoulder, quiet enough that nobody else caught it.
Harold turned. David was close, looking at him with an expression that wasn't challenge exactly — more like the expression of someone who'd sat with a dying patient long enough to know that false comfort wasn't actually comfort.
Harold took a long moment before he answered.
"I don't know if I should keep going."
David looked at the photographs on Harold's screen. Then he took the phone gently, forwarded both images to his own, and handed it back.
He put one hand briefly on Harold's shoulder — the gesture of a doctor at the end of a very long conversation.
"Then rest," he said. "Think it through tonight. Figure out which answer you can live with — the people standing right in front of you, or everyone you can't see yet."
He stepped back. "I'll take care of Cole and Shaw."
End of Chapter 92
[Reader Event Active]
500 Power Stones = +1 Extra Chapter
10 Reviews = +1 Extra Chapter
Thanks for reading!
20+advance chapters on P1treon Soulforger