Chapter 59: The Robbie Consequences
Mike Pratt called Ben on a Tuesday morning.
"Can we meet? I need to talk about... about what happened."
They met at a diner on neutral territory—neither South Side nor north side, just generic American breakfast place where neither of them belonged. Mike looked like he hadn't slept in days. Shadows under his eyes, three-day stubble, clothes rumpled.
"I didn't know," Mike said immediately. "About Robbie bringing cocaine to your house. About the revenge plan. I swear to god, Ben, I didn't know."
Ben sipped coffee that tasted like burnt water. "I believe you. You're not responsible for your brother's choices."
"He's my brother. I should've seen it coming. Should've warned you he was spiraling." Mike gripped his mug hard enough the ceramic might crack. "I knew he was using again. Knew he was obsessed with Fiona rejecting him. But I thought he'd just... I don't know, talk shit to his friends and move on. Not bring drugs to endanger a kid."
"Liam was never actually in danger. Debbie protected him exactly like I taught her."
"But he could've been. If your preparation hadn't been in place, if Debbie hadn't been trained—" Mike's voice broke. "Jesus Christ. My brother almost killed a toddler out of spite."
"He didn't though. That's what matters."
"Fiona's wearing an ankle monitor because of him!"
"Forty-five days that'll be over soon. She's okay. We're okay." Ben set down his coffee. "Why are you really here, Mike?"
Mike pulled out an envelope. "This. I wanted you to see it before I filed."
Ben opened it. Restraining order paperwork. Termination of employment. Severance of family trust access.
"You're cutting him off completely."
"I run a family business that employs people with kids. I can't have my brother—a cocaine addict who brought drugs to a home with children—anywhere near it. Legal liability aside, it's morally repugnant." Mike's jaw was set. "And the family stuff... I told my parents what he did. They agreed. No more trust fund. No more bailouts. He's on his own."
"That's harsh."
"That's consequences. Something Robbie's never actually faced because Dad always cleaned up his messes." Mike took the envelope back. "I also called the police. Gave them a statement about Robbie's drug use, his intentions, everything I knew. They're investigating him now."
Ben already knew this—had arranged it himself by providing evidence to the prosecutor. But Mike's independent action made it more legitimate.
"Thank you," Ben said. "For doing the right thing despite it being your brother."
"Fiona's a good person. Good employee, good guardian to those kids. She didn't deserve what he did." Mike stood to leave, dropped cash for both their meals. "Tell her she still has a job when house arrest ends. If she wants it."
"I will."
Mike left. Ben sat with his terrible coffee, processing the conversation. Mike had done everything right—cut ties, reported the crime, accepted consequences for family member's actions. Some rich people had integrity after all.
Robbie
Robbie's arrest happened at his apartment Thursday morning.
Two detectives with a warrant. Charges: possession with intent to distribute, child endangerment, harassment, and criminal conspiracy. Evidence included security footage, witness testimony from Mickey (paid for information), and Mike's statement about Robbie's stated intentions.
"You're arresting me for giving someone cocaine?" Robbie asked, genuinely confused through his hangover.
"We're arresting you for bringing a controlled substance to a home with children, leaving it deliberately to cause legal consequences for the resident, and endangering a minor in the process," Detective Williams clarified. "Among other charges."
"I didn't endanger any kid. I just left—"
"You left cocaine where a two-year-old could access it. That's textbook endangerment."
They cuffed him. Read his rights. Robbie's expensive apartment with its floor-to-ceiling windows suddenly felt like a cage he'd built himself.
At the station, his lawyer arrived within an hour—family money still good for something. But the evidence was overwhelming. Security footage showing him arriving with cocaine, leaving after confrontation, Fiona immediately attempting disposal. Mickey's testimony about Robbie's stated revenge plans. Mike's statement about drug use and obsession with Fiona.
"Best I can do is negotiate a plea," his lawyer said. "You're looking at two to three years if convicted at trial."
"Two years? For leaving cocaine at someone's house?"
"For child endangerment, conspiracy, and possession with intent. The Gallagher family had proactive safety measures that prevented harm—judge will see that as mitigating their culpability while aggravating yours." The lawyer reviewed files. "You deliberately brought drugs to endanger a child because a woman rejected you. That's not just possession—that's malicious intent."
Robbie sat in the interrogation room processing this. Two years. Actual prison. For revenge that didn't even work—Fiona still chose Ben, still got married, still lived her boring stable life.
And he'd destroyed himself trying to prove she was making a mistake.
Ben
Ben met with the prosecutor three weeks after Robbie's arrest.
Assistant DA Jennifer Reeves had reviewed the evidence Ben provided. Security footage, Mickey's witness statement, documentation of Robbie's harassment history. Everything building a case for aggressive prosecution.
"This is solid," Reeves said. "We can prove intent, means, and opportunity. Mr. Pratt deliberately endangered a child for revenge."
"What's he looking at?" Ben asked.
"Two to four years if he takes a plea. Five to seven if he goes to trial and loses." She flipped through files. "Judge Martinez is handling the case—same judge who sentenced Ms. Gallagher. She'll remember the family's safety protocols prevented harm. That won't help Mr. Pratt."
Ben used just a whisper of Silver Tongue. "This case should send a message. Rich kids don't get to endanger children without serious consequences."
Reeves' expression hardened slightly. "Agreed. We're pursuing maximum sentencing within guidelines. He needs to understand actions have consequences."
The power settled like oil on water—subtle influence, nothing obvious. Just ensuring the prosecutor stayed aggressive instead of accepting easy plea deals.
"Thank you for pursuing this," Ben said.
"Thank you for the evidence. Most victims don't have this level of documentation." Reeves stood to end the meeting. "We'll notify you when he's sentenced."
Ben left the courthouse feeling the weight of what he'd done. Used his powers to ensure harsh sentencing for someone whose life was already imploding. Robbie would spend years in prison partly because Ben had stacked the deck against him.
Is that justice or revenge? Does it matter when he deliberately tried to destroy Fiona's life?
He couldn't answer that. Just knew Robbie needed to be removed permanently from their orbit. Prison accomplished that.
That night, Ben told Fiona about Robbie's arrest over dinner.
The kids were eating in the living room—pizza night, minimal supervision required. Ben and Fiona sat at the kitchen table, her ankle monitor blinking green beneath the tablecloth.
"Mike cut him off completely," Ben said. "Family disowned him. He's facing two to four years for what he did."
Fiona pushed food around her plate. "That's... that's a lot."
"That's consequences for endangering a child out of spite."
"I know. I just..." She set down her fork. "I'm glad he's facing justice. But I also feel sad that someone imploded so completely over rejection."
Ben studied her face. "You're too compassionate. He tried to destroy your life."
"And failed. I'm here, we're getting married, Liam's safe. He destroyed himself trying to hurt me." She looked at her ankle monitor. "I could've been him. Addicted, revenge-driven, self-destructive. Different circumstances, that's me."
"It's not though. You made different choices."
"Because you were there. Offering stability, showing me better options, loving me through chaos." Her eyes were wet. "You saved me from becoming Robbie. That's the difference—I had someone who gave a shit. He just had money and enablers."
The insight gutted Ben. She was right—circumstances and support made all the difference between her path and Robbie's.
"I hope he gets help in prison," Fiona said quietly. "Hope he comes out better instead of worse."
"That's generous considering what he did."
"That's realistic about how cycles work. Punishment without rehabilitation just creates worse criminals." She reached for Ben's hand. "I'm grateful, by the way. For fighting for me. For making sure justice happened. For protecting our family from his revenge."
"Always," Ben said.
They finished dinner in comfortable silence. Robbie was gone—arrested, facing prison, permanently removed from their lives. The threat that had consumed Ben's preparation for months was finally, conclusively neutralized.
One less thing to worry about. One less danger on the horizon. We can actually move forward without looking over our shoulders.
Author's Note / Promotion:
Your Reviews and Power Stones are the best way to show support. They help me know what you're enjoying and bring in new readers!
You don't have to. Get instant access to more content by supporting me on Patreon. I have three options so you can pick how far ahead you want to be:
🪙 Silver Tier ($6): Read 10 chapters ahead of the public site.
👑 Gold Tier ($9): Get 15-20 chapters ahead of the public site.
💎 Platinum Tier ($15): The ultimate experience. Get new chapters the second I finish them . No waiting for weekly drops, just pure, instant access.
Your support helps me write more .
👉 Find it all at patreon.com/fanficwriter1