Chapter 55: The Cocaine Incident - Part 2
The Cook County Jail visiting room smelled like industrial cleaner and desperation.
Ben sat across from Fiona at 7 PM, a plexiglass barrier between them, phones connecting their conversation while guards watched from the periphery.
She looked smaller in the orange jumpsuit. Tired. Scared in ways he'd never seen before.
"How are the kids?" First question, always the family.
"Good. Debbie's a hero—she protected Liam perfectly. V and Kev are helping. Everyone's worried but okay."
"And you?"
"Terrified. But fighting. I hired Jonathan Price—best defense attorney for drug cases in Cook County. He'll be at your arraignment tomorrow."
"Arraignment." Fiona laughed bitterly. "Never thought I'd need to know what that word meant."
"It's the hearing where they decide bail and formally charge you. Price thinks he can get the charges dismissed entirely if we present the security footage showing Robbie brought the drugs without your knowledge."
"You have security footage?"
Because I've been preparing for this exact scenario since February. "Yeah. Had cameras installed a while back. They show everything—Robbie arriving, leaving after you refused, you immediately trying to clean up."
Relief washed over her face. "So this might actually be okay?"
"It might. The case is weak. Small amount, clear attempt at disposal, child was protected, evidence the drugs weren't yours. Price is optimistic."
"Optimistic about me not going to prison." She said it like testing the words, seeing how they felt. "This is insane. Forty-eight hours ago we were planning our wedding. Now I'm in jail facing felony charges."
"We'll still have the wedding. July twenty-seventh. I promise."
"How can you promise that? I might be in prison."
"You won't be. Because I won't let you be." Ben pressed his hand against the plexiglass. She matched the gesture from her side. "We've survived everything else—poverty, violence, my criminal past, Frank's bullshit, relationship crises. We'll survive this too."
"You always say that."
"And I'm always right."
She almost smiled. "Your confidence is kind of annoying."
"My confidence is rooted in preparation. I've been ready for this exact situation for months. Narcan positioned, family trained, lawyer researched, footage recorded. Every piece was in place."
"Except the piece that keeps me out of jail."
"That piece is coming. Tomorrow. Trust Price. Trust the footage. Trust that we've got this."
The guard indicated time was up. Fiona stood reluctantly.
"Ben? If this goes wrong—if I end up with prison time—don't wait for me. Find someone else, have the life you deserve."
"Don't." His voice was sharp. "Don't do that noble sacrifice bullshit. You're not going to prison and I'm not leaving you. We're getting married in six weeks. Count on it."
"Six weeks seems impossible from in here."
"Good thing you've got me making the impossible happen."
They hung up the phones. She was led back to her cell. Ben left the jail and drove home through Chicago twilight, his Danger Intuition finally quiet.
The immediate crisis passed. Liam safe. Fiona arrested but not endangered. Now comes the legal fight. The part where money and preparation either save us or fail.
Lip arrived from MIT at midnight.
He'd driven straight through—ten hours of fury fueling the journey. Ben was still awake, reviewing the security footage Price would present tomorrow.
"Where's Fiona?" Lip demanded.
"Jail. Arraignment tomorrow at 9 AM."
"What the fuck happened?"
Ben explained for the third time that night. Lip listened with increasing rage, then pulled out his phone.
"What are you doing?"
"Finding Robbie Pratt's address. We're paying him a visit."
"No. We're not." Ben grabbed Lip's phone. "We're fighting this legally. Violence makes everything worse."
"He got my sister arrested!"
"And we're going to prove that in court tomorrow. With evidence, testimony, and legal defense. Not by assaulting him and giving prosecutors more ammunition."
"So we just let him get away with it?"
"We let the legal system handle it. If that fails, then we discuss alternatives. But not before."
Lip was vibrating with barely contained violence. Ben recognized the impulse—had felt it himself for hours. The desire to hurt Robbie physically for the damage he'd caused.
But violence wouldn't free Fiona. Only preparation and legal strategy would.
"Trust me," Ben said. "I've been ready for this for months. The lawyer's good, the evidence is solid, we have a real chance at dismissal tomorrow."
"And if we don't get dismissal?"
"Then we fight at trial. But we don't throw away Fiona's chances by committing assault the night before her arraignment."
Lip eventually calmed, though fury still radiated from him. They stayed up together, reviewing the footage frame by frame, building the narrative Price would present.
Robbie arriving at 3:02 PM. Entering the house. Leaving at 3:12 PM—visible cocaine still in hand as he left, proving he removed some but left evidence deliberately. Fiona's immediate trip to the bathroom. Frantic cleaning visible through the kitchen camera's angle.
"This should work," Lip said finally. "Proves malicious intent on Robbie's part."
"Should. But law isn't always logical."
"Comforting."
"Realistic."
The arraignment was scheduled for 9 AM Saturday.
Ben arrived at 8:30 with Price, Lip, V, and Kevin. They sat in the courthouse waiting area while Price reviewed final strategy.
"The footage is compelling," Price said. "Shows clear timeline of Robbie bringing drugs, Fiona attempting disposal. Combined with testimony from the twelve-year-old who protected the toddler, we have strong argument for dismissal."
"What are the odds?" Ben asked.
"Sixty-forty in our favor. Judge might dismiss outright if she's sympathetic. Might reduce charges to misdemeanor. Worst case, keeps felony charges but sets reasonable bail."
"And Robbie?"
"I've filed a motion to charge him as well—cocaine possession, child endangerment, trespassing, harassment. Whether prosecution pursues is their call."
At 9:15, they were called into the courtroom.
Fiona was led in wearing orange, hands cuffed. She found Ben's eyes immediately—frightened but trying for brave.
"All rise. The Honorable Judge Patricia Martinez presiding."
Judge Martinez was mid-fifties, stern expression, reputation for toughness on drug cases. Ben's stomach sank slightly.
The prosecutor presented charges: possession of a controlled substance, child endangerment. Asked for $50,000 bail given flight risk and severity.
Price stood. "Your Honor, defense requests charges be dismissed entirely. We have security footage proving the defendant did not possess drugs willingly, attempted immediate disposal, and the endangered child was never actually in danger."
"Show me the footage."
They played it. The courtroom watched Robbie arrive, enter, leave ten minutes later. Watched Fiona immediately go to the bathroom. Watched her frantic cleaning.
Martinez studied the screen. "Who is the male individual?"
"Robert Pratt Jr. Son of Robert Pratt Sr., owner of Patsy's Pies franchise. He brought cocaine to Ms. Gallagher's home without permission as retaliation for romantic rejection."
"Can you prove that?"
"Ms. Gallagher told officers this during questioning. We have testimony from her twelve-year-old sister that Mr. Pratt appeared uninvited and the older sister immediately removed the toddler from potential danger."
"Where was Ms. Gallagher when the child was removed?"
"Downstairs refusing Mr. Pratt's offers of drugs and demanding he leave. The footage shows she never accepted or wanted the contraband."
Martinez reviewed paperwork. Ben held his breath. Fiona's hands were shaking.
"Prosecution, response?"
The prosecutor stood. "Your Honor, drugs were found in the defendant's home. Regardless of origin, that constitutes possession. Child endangerment applies because a toddler was present during drug activity."
"The toddler was removed before drugs appeared and never exposed to contraband," Price countered. "That's responsible parenting, not endangerment."
Martinez was quiet for several seconds that felt like hours.
"Motion to dismiss child endangerment charge is granted. The child was clearly protected. However, possession charge stands—drugs were present in defendant's home, found through legal search. I'm reducing to misdemeanor possession, setting bail at $2,000, and scheduling trial for August 15th if defendant wishes to fight the charge."
Fiona's shoulders slumped. Not dismissal, but not felony charges either.
"Additionally," Martinez continued, "I'm ordering the State's Attorney to investigate Robert Pratt Jr. for cocaine possession and harassment based on evidence presented. If he brought illegal substances to Ms. Gallagher's home as retaliation, he should face appropriate consequences."
Price stood. "Thank you, Your Honor. Defense posts $2,000 bail and requests trial date be moved to September due to scheduled wedding in late July."
"Granted. Trial set for September 12th. Ms. Gallagher, you're released on bail with conditions: no contact with Robert Pratt Jr., drug testing monthly until trial, and continued residence in Cook County."
The gavel banged. Fiona was led out to process release paperwork.
Ben exhaled for what felt like the first time in hours.
"That's the best outcome we could've hoped for," Price said. "Misdemeanor instead of felony, reasonable bail, and Robbie's being investigated. She'll likely get probation if convicted, possibly suspended sentence given circumstances."
"Not dismissal though."
"Judges rarely dismiss entirely on arraignment. But misdemeanor conviction won't destroy her life. She can still work, still parent, still live normally."
Ben paid the $2,000 bail. Another chunk of savings gone—down to $4,000 now. Two months of careful accumulation spent in forty-eight hours of crisis.
But Fiona would be free. That was worth every penny.
They released her at 11:30 AM.
She emerged wearing the clothes she'd been arrested in—now rumpled and slept-in for two nights. Ben was waiting in the lobby with everyone.
"You're out," he said stupidly.
"I'm out." She hugged him hard enough to hurt. "Misdemeanor instead of felony. Trial in September."
"Which we'll win."
"You keep saying that."
"Keep being right about it."
V descended with fierce hugs. Kevin offered congratulations. Lip's expression was tight—relieved she was free but furious about the remaining charges.
"What about Robbie?" Fiona asked.
"Being investigated. Martinez ordered it specifically. If they charge him, he faces the same you do plus harassment."
"Good." No sympathy in her voice. "He tried to destroy my life out of spite. He should face consequences."
They went home. The house looked different after everything—normal rooms now associated with crisis and arrest. The bathroom where Fiona had frantically cleaned. The living room where Robbie had left his revenge.
The kids mobbed Fiona the second she entered. Debbie crying with relief, Carl trying to look tough but obviously emotional, Ian calm but pleased. Liam climbed into her lap, oblivious to the crisis he'd been protected from.
"My hero," Fiona said, kissing Debbie's forehead. "You saved Liam exactly like Ben taught you."
"I just did what I was supposed to."
"That's what makes you a hero."
That night, after the kids were asleep and the house was finally quiet, Ben and Fiona lay in their bed together.
"We're still getting married, right?" she asked.
"July twenty-seventh. I promised."
"Even with criminal charges hanging over me?"
"Even with. The charges won't stick. Price is confident we'll win at trial."
"But if we don't?"
"Then we handle it together. Like everything else."
She was quiet for several minutes. "Do you regret it? Choosing me? All the chaos I bring?"
"Never." Ben turned to face her. "You didn't bring this chaos—Robbie did. You made all the right choices. Refused drugs, protected Liam, tried to dispose of contraband immediately. You did everything perfectly."
"Except I'm still facing criminal charges."
"Because the system isn't perfect. But we have evidence, testimony, and a good lawyer. We'll survive this."
"You always say that."
"Still true every time."
She kissed him, tasting like jail food and exhaustion and relief. "Six weeks until the wedding. Think we can make it without another crisis?"
My Danger Intuition is quiet for the first time in months. The major threat passed. Liam's safe, Fiona's free pending trial, preparations worked despite imperfect results.
"Yeah," Ben said. "I think we can make it."
But privately, he knew they still had September's trial ahead. Still had to prove Fiona's innocence legally. Still had to get through a wedding while criminal charges hung over them.
One crisis resolved. Another waiting. But we're together, we're alive, and Liam was never harmed. That's victory by South Side standards.
They fell asleep engaged, awaiting trial, planning a wedding that would happen despite criminal justice system interference.
Six weeks until July twenty-seventh. The date circled in red on their calendar, promising forever if they could just survive until then.
Author's Note / Promotion:
Your Reviews and Power Stones are the best way to show support. They help me know what you're enjoying and bring in new readers!
You don't have to. Get instant access to more content by supporting me on Patreon. I have three options so you can pick how far ahead you want to be:
🪙 Silver Tier ($6): Read 10 chapters ahead of the public site.
👑 Gold Tier ($9): Get 15-20 chapters ahead of the public site.
💎 Platinum Tier ($15): The ultimate experience. Get new chapters the second I finish them . No waiting for weekly drops, just pure, instant access.
Your support helps me write more .
👉 Find it all at patreon.com/fanficwriter1