Cherreads

Chapter 12 - The Discussion

It's almost impressive how predictable this moment felt when I walked in hete.

"Molly," my mother says gently. "We're not trying to control you," she begins carefully. "We just want to understand."

"That's fair," I say.

Dad studies my face. "You know about his father."

"I do now. " I say, looking down and feeling ashamed of myself.

"A notorious ex-convict isn't a small detail."

"I didn't think it was." I say, still looking down.

Mom folds her hands. "And you're comfortable with that?" Comfortable isn't the word I'd use.

"I'm aware of it," I say calmly. "There's a difference."

Dad's eyes narrow slightly in evaluation. "You believe he's nothing like his father?"

"I believe he doesn't want to be."

"That's not the same thing."

"No," I agree. "It isn't." They both pause at that. I don't rush to fill silence. I've learned that silence makes people say more.

Dad exhales slowly. "Molly, history matters."

"It does."

"Patterns repeat."

"Sometimes."

Mom tilts her head. "And sometimes?"

"Sometimes people spend their whole lives trying not to become what they came from."

My father leans back in his chair. "You sound very certain."

"I'm not certain," I correct gently. "I'm observant."

Mom's expression softens slightly. "What have you observed?"

I think before answering.

"He doesn't talk about his father unless someone forces it. When people whisper, he pretends not to hear. He leaves places before situations escalate."

Dad frowns faintly. "That could mean he's hiding something."

"Or that he's careful," I say evenly.

Mom watches me closely. "You care about him."

"No."

Dad nods slowly. "We're not questioning your feelings."

"You're questioning his character."

"We're questioning the risk."

I rest my elbows lightly on the table. "What exactly are you afraid of?"

Dad answers immediately. "That one day you'll see something you ignored."

Mom adds quietly, "That you'll be hurt."

I let that settle.

"I'm not ignoring anything an I can't get hurt," I say.

"Feelings can blur judgment," Dad replies.

"They can," I agree. "But they don't erase it."

Mom studies me. "Has he ever given you a reason to doubt him?"

"No."

"Not even once?"

I consider carefully.

"He avoids talking about his father," I admit.

Dad's jaw tightens slightly. "That's significant."

"It's understandable."

"Why?"

"Because imagine being introduced to every room as someone's mistake."

That one lands.

"Yes."

Dad folds his arms. "And what if doing so isn't enough?"

"It has to be," I say quietly. They exchange a look.

Dad sighs. "Molly, people are shaped by their environments."

"Yes."

"And crime leaves marks."

"Yes."

He waits for me to argue. I don't.

"I'm not saying he isn't affected by his past," I continue. "I'm saying being affected isn't the same as repeating it."

Mom nods slowly. "That's true."

Dad studies me like he's recalculating something.

"You're very calm about this," he says.

"I don't see the benefit in panicking." A small smile touches my mother's lips.

Dad remains serious. "If we asked you to step back from him?"

I inhale slowly before answering.

"I'd ask why."

"Because we're your parents."

"I know," I say gently. "And I respect that. But I'd still ask why."

Dad holds my gaze.

"Because we think you're underestimating the weight of his background."

"And I think you might be overestimating it."

Mom reaches across the table and covers my hand with hers.

"We just don't want you tied to something that could pull you down."

"I understand."

"Do you?"

"Yes, I do , " I say. "You're not judging him. You're protecting me."

Dad exhales quietly. "Exactly."

I nod once.

"But protection doesn't always mean distance," I add.

Dad tilts his head. "Explain."

"If you want to know who he is, watch him. Talk to him. Don't just study his father's record."

Mom glances at Dad thoughtfully.

"You'd want us to get to know him?" she asks.

"Yes."

Dad looks almost surprised. "You're not afraid we'll find something you don't like?"

"If you do," I say calmly, "then I'd rather know." Silence stretches between us. Dad taps the table once, thinking.

"You're serious about him," he says finally.

"Yes."

"Serious enough to risk being wrong?"

"Yes."

Mom squeezes my hand gently. "You're growing up."

"I am," I reply.

Dad's voice softens slightly. "We can't promise we'll ever be fully comfortable with his background."

"I'm not asking you to be."

"What are you asking?"

"That you judge him by his actions." Dad considers that.

"And if his actions change?"

"Then I will too."

Mom studies my face carefully, searching for recklessness. Unfortunately, she doesn't find it.

Dad leans back slowly. "You're not blinded."

"Of course I'm not."

"You're choosing."

"Yes."

Another long pause. Finally, Dad nods once. "We won't forbid you from seeing him."

Relief flickers somewhere inside me, but I don't show it.

"But," he continues, "we'll be paying attention."

"That's reasonable."

Mom smiles faintly. "You handled this well."

"I prepared," I admit.

Dad raises an eyebrow. "You expected this conversation?"

"I know you." That earns the smallest smile from him. Mom stands and begins gathering the plates again, tension easing just slightly. As I stand to help.

Dad says quietly, "If you ever see something that feels wrong, you come to us."

"I will."

"And Molly?"

"Yes?"

"We're not your enemies."

"I know." And I do. Because this wasn't a battle. It was caution meeting conviction. And for now, neither of us won. But neither of us lost either.

The day goes by like the wind, nothing special happens after the discussion with my parents. But I guess I've learned my lesson.

Never hide people in the attic. Anyway, even though my parents didn't allow my see Jason, not that I care, I would still see him at school. They just forgot that.

Now that the problem is resolved, I would like to go back to my world formation. I think I stopped at the mental restaurant before mom called me that night.

Let's add a park and a pet. A cat to be specific.

More Chapters