The 3-4 scoreline struck like a sledgehammer swung with full force, crashing down on every Manchester City heart brutally.
Each number on the electronic scoreboard felt like a personal insult, a public humiliation broadcasted to the world.
The home team had lost. At the Etihad. After leading 3-1. The math was simple, but the psychological impact was catastrophic.
Pellegrini stood frozen in place near the technical area looking like a statue carved from disappointment and disbelief. His face had turned cold, hard and completely drained of any life and color.
His mind was already calculating the damage.
Five-point swing in the title race meant the momentum was completely reversed. Confidence would be potentially shattered. And the Christmas fixture list stretching ahead gave no time to recover mentally.
On the pitch, City's players looked like someone had physically extracted their souls, leaving only empty shells mechanically going through post-match motions.
Hart sat collapsed on the turf with his arms propping himself up from behind, head tilted back toward the night sky. His eyes were blank, hollow, staring at absolutely nothing or perhaps staring at the career-defining save he'd failed to make, replaying Julien's panenka over and over in his mind's eye.
That gentle chip. That audacious piece of skill. The ball floating over his diving body while he was completely powerless to prevent it.
The image would haunt him.
Kompany stood stiffly with both hands on his hips, eyebrows twisted into a knot of frustration so tight it looked painful.
His lips moved constantly, muttering the same words over and over like a broken record, like a mantra that might somehow change reality if repeated enough times:
"This shouldn't have happened. This shouldn't have happened. Not like this."
His captain's armband felt heavy, heavier than it ever had before. He'd failed to organize the defense when it mattered most. Failed to prevent the collapse. Failed to lead his team to victory when they'd been gifted a two-goal advantage.
Yaya Touré simply walked away from everyone else, seeking privacy in his defeat, his usual imposing presence was reduced to a lonely figure trudging toward the tunnel.
Near the substitutes' bench, Nasri was suffering perhaps most intensely of all—not from physical exhaustion, but from psychological torment of his own making.
His eyes looked poisonous, venomous, burning with rage locked onto Julien's celebrating figure with intensity. His expression was so dark, so twisted with jealousy and resentment, it could have dripped venom onto the turf.
Watching De Rocca surrounded by ecstatic teammates, becoming the undisputed center of attention, the hero who'd shattered City's winning streak with a hat-trick and a record-equaling performance—a violent surge of jealousy erupted from deep in Nasri's chest overwhelming his rationality completely.
The feeling was intense like a burning sensation in his gut that spread through his entire body, making his hands shake, making his jaw clench so hard his teeth hurt.
He ground his teeth together, thinking with bitter viciousness: Him again! Always fucking him! Why does HE always get to be the star? What does he have that I don't? I'm French too! I'm talented too! Why am I the one being substituted while he scores hat-tricks?
The comparisons were inevitable and brutal.
Both French of similar age brackets.
Both even attacking midfielders now.
But one was the Premier League's newest superstar, equaling scoring records and winning matches single-handedly. The other had been pulled off the pitch in the 78th minute, deemed surplus to requirements, watching the finale from the bench.
The jealousy was eroding, eating away at him from the inside.
But anger changed nothing. Jealousy accomplished nothing. The scoreboard's 4-3 stood like an insurmountable chasm between what was and what should have been, between victory and defeat, between glory and humiliation.
Soon after Liverpool's celebration concluded, the referee signaled for play to resume.
Tweet!!
Agüero kicked off to Milner. City's final counterattack was as rushed and futile as a drowning man's last desperate thrashing.
Players forced their exhausted bodies forward through sheer willpower, legs that felt like lead were somehow finding one more push.
In the dying seconds of stoppage time, Yaya Touré managed to stabilize possession in midfield, then launched a hopeful long ball toward Agüero lurking at the edge of the penalty area.
Agüero met it, summoning the last dregs of energy remaining in his body, swinging his right foot through the ball with everything he had left.
The desperation was visible in his technique. It seemed too eager and desperate for the miracle goal.
The ball sailed high over the crossbar, it was not even close then disappeared into the stands behind Hart's goal.
And after that final wayward shot soared into the Etihad night...
The referee raised his right arm high, then blew his whistle with three sharp blasts.
TWEET! TWEET! TWEET!
The sound cut through the stadium atmosphere, bringing conclusion to the incredible drama.
The scoreline was set in stone: Manchester City 3-4 Liverpool.
Liverpool had completed a stunning comeback victory away from home, delivering a dramatic winner against one of the league's title favorites.
Instantly, Liverpool's players could no longer contain themselves. Every last reserve of emotional control vanished.
Some players, the moment the whistle sounded, felt their legs give out completely. They collapsed directly onto the turf, gasping for air in huge, ragged breaths.
Henderson who'd been sprinting box-to-box for ninety-plus minutes lay spread on his back with both hands clutching his chest.
His ribcage heaved violently with each breath. Sweat poured down his face, soaking into the grass beneath him. He didn't even have the strength left to raise an arm in celebration.
His entire body had been pushed beyond its limits, and now it demanded payment.
Others remained on their feet but swayed unsteadily, embracing teammates, tears mixing with sweat, voices were hoarse from ninety minutes of constant communication and encouragement.
On the touchline, Klopp walked first toward Pellegrini, extending his right hand with courtesy.
Pellegrini gripped it perfunctorily—the handshake was symbolic, mechanical, without any warmth.
He said nothing. Not even a single word. Then he turned and walked directly toward the tunnel, disappearing into the bowels of the stadium.
Klopp didn't take offense. He understood defeat's sting, the need for privacy in moments like these.
Instead, he turned and strode quickly toward his own players, a brilliant smile was spreading across his face genuine joy was radiating from every feature.
He moved meticulously to each player individually. Whether they were celebrating wildly or lying exhausted on the turf recovering, he crouched down to offer high-fives or pulled them into powerful embraces.
When he reached Henderson, still sprawled on his back, Klopp gently patted his shoulder, smiling warmly. "Well done, young man. You fought brilliantly. Absolutely brilliantly."
Henderson managed a weak thumbs-up, too exhausted for words.
Julien and Gerrard embraced near the center circle, both men were grinning despite their complete physical exhaustion, despite legs that felt like they might give out at any moment.
This match had been defined by multiple crucial moments, but Gerrard's thunderbolt equalizer stood above them all—the moment that brought Liverpool back from the brink of defeat, that gave them life when the outcome seemed inevitable, that transformed resignation into belief.
The captain pulled Julien close, one arm wrapped around his shoulders, the other hand patting his back firmly with genuine pride and affection.
"Beautifully done, Julien. Absolutely beautifully done." Gerrard's voice carried warmth and conviction despite the exhaustion. "Liverpool's future—it belongs to you now. You've earned it."
Julien could hear the exhaustion clearly in his captain's voice—not just physical tiredness, it was also the accumulated weight of fifteen years carrying this club on his shoulders, fifteen years being the man everyone looked to when things went wrong, fifteen years of last-ditch tackles and crucial goals and leadership in the darkest moments.
This match had pushed Gerrard to his absolute limits and perhaps beyond. From deep-lying midfield orchestration to forward runs into the box, from tactical discipline to that thunderous equalizer, he'd demonstrated through ninety-plus minutes of action what captaincy truly meant.
But the cost was visible in every line of his face, in the way his chest heaved, in the slight tremor in his legs.
As Gerrard released the embrace and took a half-step back to look at the confident young player before him—still looking fresh-faced despite ninety minutes of intense football, still moving with that athletic grace that seemed effortless—a strange, melancholy feeling splashed over him completely unconsciously.
'I'm getting old.'
The thought arrived like an unwelcome guest but carried undeniable truth.
The tireless running that used to come so naturally, that used to feel like breathing—now every sprint hurt, every recovery took longer. The thunderous long-range strikes that once felt effortless now required conscious thought about technique, about body positioning, about follow-through.
That wind-like boy who'd burst onto the Liverpool scene at seventeen, who'd terrorized Premier League defenses with endless energy and incredible determination for fifteen years, who'd dragged this club through countless battles through sheer force of will—he was aging.
Time was undefeated. Even Steven Gerrard couldn't outrun it forever.
The realization sat heavy in his chest mixing bitter with sweet.
But looking at Julien—at the confidence radiating from him, at the natural leadership qualities already emerging, at the technical brilliance combined with mental strength that so few players possessed, Gerrard felt profound satisfaction overwhelm the melancholy.
Liverpool's future finally had someone worthy of carrying the torch forward. Someone who wouldn't just maintain standards but might even exceed them.
The succession wasn't just likely. It was inevitable. And it was right.
Gerrard had spent so many years worrying about what would happen to Liverpool when he eventually declined, when his body could no longer match his ambitions, when the next generation failed to step up.
But looking at Julien, those fears vanished.
The club would be fine. Better than fine.
Liverpool's spirit—that refusal to surrender, that absolute conviction that any deficit could be overturned, that unshakeable belief in victory regardless of circumstances, it wasn't dying with his generation.
It was being reborn in this teenager who'd just scored a hat-trick at the Etihad, who'd equaled a scoring record many thought untouchable, who'd delivered a panenka penalty in the 92nd minute with ice in his veins.
The tradition would continue.
Liverpool would endure.
In the post-match press conference, Pellegrini's expression remained dark, his body language was closed off and defensive.
"I have to admit—we lost a very difficult match. Liverpool showed tremendous resilience. They deserve this victory."
He paused, clearly forcing himself through the professional obligation.
"We were two goals ahead. But after their tactical adjustments, our defense became loose, especially when we tried to contract and control possession to protect our advantage. The players' thinking wasn't unified enough. We gave Liverpool too many counter-attacking opportunities, too much space to apply pressure."
His hands gestured with frustration.
"The Christmas fixture congestion has caused massive physical depletion across the squad. That's a significant reason why we couldn't withstand their late pressure."
When asked specifically about Julien's performance, his tone showed resignation.
"Julien is an exceptionally talented player. Tonight his performance was flawless. Hat-trick. Equaling the Premier League single-season scoring record. That kind of performance speaks for itself regarding his quality."
Pellegrini's expression darkened further.
"His speed and finishing ability created far too many problems for our defensive line. Especially that final penalty—he showed composure beyond his years with that panenka."
He stood abruptly, signaling the end of his participation.
"The defeat has happened. We cannot change the result. What we must do now is adjust our mentality as quickly as possible and prepare for the fixtures ahead."
Without another word or smile, he left the room.
________________________________________________________
Check out my patreon where you can read more chapters:
patreon.com/LorianFiction
Thanks for your support!